The Review

March 1996 Issue

articles

Future Freedom and Freedom of Contract

John Stuart Mill defended the law’s refusal to enforce self-enslavement contracts on the ground that the ‘principle of freedom cannot require that he [the would-be slave] be free not to be free.' Mill’s statement has received much attention over the years, but little support. Critics argue that Mill’s position is paternalistic, if not actually incoherent, and that the legal bar on contracts of self-enslavement can be explained more easily on the basis of a concern for procedural and/or substantive unfairness. In this article, I defend Mill’s statement. I shall argue that a concern for ‘future freedom’ justifies not only the courts’ approach to self-enslavement contracts, but also the courts’ scrutiny of a number of other (as I shall call them ‘autonomy-endangering agreement'.

Stephen A. Smith

Losses of Chances in the Law

Let us begin with two well-known principles. The first is that the standard of proof in civil cases is the balance of probabilities. The second is that in the tort of negligence the standard of proof is operated by using the ‘but for’ test: the negligence has to be a necessary cause of the loss. In most negligence cases, these principles occasion no controversy. The problems begin with those cases where it is difficult to decide what would have happened without the negligence. A first impression of these cases is that the decisions are arbitrary and inconsistent, and this is reinforced by the paucity of the judicial reasoning. In this article it is argued that a philosophical analysis enables us to grasp the distinction between the cases.

Helen Reece

Fact‐finding in Inter‐state Adjudication

Inter-state disputes that have arisen for adjudication before the International Court of Justice reveal variations and inconsistencies in the nature of judicial fact-finding. Justifying these variations as the products of coincidence or error is unsatisfactory and fails to illuminate the underlying reasons for factual decisions. These reasons remain shrouded in uncertainty, leaving the rationale for the peculiar nature of fact-finding to speculation. This article suggests a theoretical framework within which decisions of fact by the International Court can be scrutinised and rationalisations sought between factual findings and substantive verdicts.

Saju Jacob

Defendants in Consumer Protection Statutes: A Search for Consistency

A variety of statutes in the United Kingdom use the criminal law to protect consumer interests. Chief among these are the Trade Descriptions Act 1968, the Consumer Protection Act 1987, the Food Safety Act 1990 and the Property Misdescriptions Act 1991. Although these statutes cover similar matters, they provide very different rules about who can be prosecuted for breach of their provisions. This article examines who is, and who should be, open to prosecution under these statutes. It is argued that there is no justification for the differences in approach which currently exist, and that those differences have resulted from Parliament’s inadequate consideration of the issue. It is important that a consistent approach is adopted, and I will suggest appropriate reforms.

Peter Cartwright

legislation

Pensions Act 1995

This Act effects three major reforms to the law of pensions. It introduces a new measure for regulating occupational pension schemes; it equalises the state pension ages of men and women; and it restructures the link between state and occupational pension schemes. At the risk of over-simplification, I would argue that these separate reforms are linked by a common set of assumptions. Namely, that compulsory pension provision at adequate levels is unaffordable; and that government must encourage as many of the population as possible to make their own private pension provision. The government is cutting back on the state pension scheme and will not make adequate levels of private pensions compulsory.

Richard Nobles

Better Late than Never: The Reform of the Law on the Sale of Goods Forming Part of a Bulk

Until September 1995, contracts worth millions of pounds were being concluded regularly in the commodity markets’ of the United Kingdom in which the purchasers of goods forming part of bulk cargoes or bulk storage were at grave risk if the seller became insolvent. Clearly, reform of the rules on passing of property was required to meet the needs of commerce. Surprisingly, however, reform did not immediately follow from the discovery that the law was defective with regards to goods bought from bulk.

Tom Burns

cases

Damages for Breach of Contract — Compensation and ‘Personal Preferences’: Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth

There has been much debate surrounding the circumstances when it is possible to recover cost of reinstatement damages for breach of contract rather than the difference in the property’s value where the cost of reinstatement greatly exceeds that difference in value. In England, prior to the decision in Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth, a compromise position had been reached so that, as a general principle, it had been accepted that the larger cost of reinstatement damages would be the appropriate measure of damage if it could be shown that (a) it was reasonable to carry out the repair work, and (b) the employer had either cured the defect or intended to cure it. It appears that the majority of the Court of Appeal in Ruxley became so preoccupied with the question of the appropriate measure of damages that they neglected to correctly identify the loss itself.

Jill Poole

Misrepresentation and Non‐disclosure in Insurance Law — Identical Twins or Separate Issues?

In Pan Atlantic Co Ltd and Another v Pine Top Insurance Co Ltd, the House of
Lords again tackled the vexed question of the meaning of materiality in English
insurance law. The earlier CTI decision has been much criticised and many saw
Pan Atlantic as an opportunity for the House of Lords to set the law of insurance back on the right track on the issue of materiality; their Lordships, on a bare majority, rejected the opportunity and approved the CTI decision.

John Birds & Norma J. Hird

Law, Labour and Mental Harm

Employers are under a duty (arising concurrently in tort and contract) to exercise reasonable care so as to protect their workers from reasonably foreseeable work-related mental harm. That the law comprehends this form of harm was established by Colman J in the case of Walker v Northumberland County Council, in which the plaintiff suffered a permanently disabling mental breakdown having been unreasonably exposed to a ‘deluge of work.’ His decision is noteworthy on account of the emphasis it gives to the balancing of plaintiff- and defendant-related interests when determining whether a (negligence-based) duty of care has been breached, the light which it throws on the concept of reasonable care (as it features in the law of negligence) and the questions that it raises concerning the relationship between tort and contract.

Lesley Dolding & Richard Mullender

review article

The Process is the Rule and the Punishment is the Process

Review of Andrew Ashworth, The Criminal Process: An Evaluative Study, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994, 315 pp, hb £45.00, pb £12.95 and Andrew Sanders and Richard Young, Criminal Justice, London: Butterworths, 1994, 496 pp, pb £18.95.

Fig leaf or no, The criminal justice system is real, with life-altering consequences for those caught up in it. The proportion of male citizens convicted of a listed offence by middle age is now estimated to be approaching forty per cent13 and, to adapt the title of a well-known book on the subject, for those caught up in it, the criminal process is the rule and the punishment is the process. The turmoil of current events therefore makes it imperative that we are clear about what principles should govern the criminal justice system. We need a road map to guide us through the competing claims currently being pressed. It is a need that the Runciman Commission Report largely failed to meet. How well do these two books offer guidance with regard to the contemporary debate?

Rod Morgan

book reviews

March 1996 Book Reviews

Malcolm Jarvis on Richard Bellamy, Vittorio Bufacchi and Dario Castiglione (eds), Democracy and Constitutional Culture in the Union of Europe

Costas Douzinas on Ian Ward, Law and Literature: Possibilities and Perspectives

Hazel Carty on Laddie, Prescott and Vitoria, The Modern Law of Copyright and Designs

Hazel Carty on George Metaxas‐Maranghidis (ed), Intellectual Property Laws of Europe

Stephen Weatherill on Ian Harden, State Aid: Community Law and Policy; Michael Moran and Tony Prosser (eds), Privatization and Regulatory Change in Europe; Lord Cockfield, The European Union: Creating the Single Market

Donal Nolan on Roger Brownsword, Geraint Howells and Thomas Wilhelmsson (eds), Welfarism in Contract Law

James Driscoll on Stuart Bridge, Residential Leases

Various

The Review

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES