The Review

January 2022 Issue

articles

Fat Cats, Production Networks, and the Right to Fair Pay

Should there be a legal right to fair pay so that anyone might challenge the relative fairness of their pay? Standards of fairness should be discovered in principles of interpersonal justice. These contain an egalitarian impulse providing moral reasons for rejecting market rates of pay. Appropriate regulations enacting a legal right to fair pay are explored with a view to achieving reflexive yet effective regulation using works councils to fix outer limits to wage dispersal ratios.

Hugh Collins

Falling into Line? The Hostile Environment and the Legend of the ‘Judges’ Revolt’

In 2012 the Government made a number of controversial changes to the Immigration Rules, which it claimed would ‘comprehensively reform the approach taken towards ECHR Article 8 in immigration cases’. This paper examines the judicial response, arguing that the courts ‘fell into line’, adapting human rights law to the government's aims through unprincipled and opportunistic techniques, whilst inflicting hardship and injustice on working-class British citizens in particular.

Christopher Rowe

legislation

The EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement – Exceptional Circumstances or a new Paradigm for EU External Relations?

In the final days of 2020, the European Union and the United Kingdom concluded a Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) covering a broad range of policy areas. Contrary to the argument of the EU institutions, the agreement will have broad implications for the understanding of the EU's external competence and Member States’ ability to act in areas that are national competence and rely on national budgets.

Christina Eckes & Päivi Leino-Sandberg

cases

A Struggle for Competence: National Security, Surveillance and the Scope of EU Law at the Court of Justice of European Union

In Privacy International and Quadrature Du Net, the Grand Chamber of the CJEU ruled that the e-Privacy Directive generally prevents bulk retention and transmission of traffic and location data, unless Member States can prove serious threats to national security. While Privacy International unequivocally asserts CJEU's authority in national security and is a victory for data protection, Quadrature Du Net does not oppose indiscriminate data retention in principle and is an ambivalent response to political pressure.

Monika Zalnieriute

Citizen Led Policing in the Digital Realm: Paedophile Hunters and Article 8 in the case of Sutherland v Her Majesty's Advocate

In Sutherland v Her Majesty's Advocate, the Supreme Court unanimously dismissed an appeal which argued that the use of communications obtained by a paedophile hunter group as evidence in criminal prosecution was a violation of Article 8 of the ECHR. The case raises fundamental questions of the scope of the right to private life as regards to the content of communications and the role played by private actors in the criminal justice process.

Allison M. Holmes

review article

book reviews

Review of Simon Stern, Maksymilian Del Mar and Bernadette Meyler (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Law and Humanities, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2020, xix + 892 pp, hb £125.00

This Handbook contains 45 well-researched chapters, evenly distributed over four parts and covering a wide range of topics. While in earlier interdisciplinary scholarship the one discipline was often analysed in terms of its auxiliary function or specific disciplinary relationship to the other, the Handbook provides richer understandings. It has given its authors free rein to explore what they consider to be the ‘most urgent’ topics for the future of Law and Humanities.

Jeanne Gaakeer

Review of Ferraz, Octavio L.M., Health as a Human Right: The Politics and Judicialisation of Health in Brazil, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021, xxii + 340 pp, hb £85.00.

There is no better (or, you might say, worse) time to talk about the right to health in Brazil – the focus of Octavio L.M. Ferraz's new book. The book is a fine piece of legal scholarship that aptly combines normative reflections with original and secondary-sourced empirical material produced and gathered by the author in over two decades of studying health law in the country, making him a pioneer in empirical studies on health litigation in Brazil.

Natalia Pires de Vasconcelos

Review of Ambos, Kai et al, Core Concepts in Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, Volume 1: Anglo-German Dialogues, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020, 504 pp, hb £110

Comparative criminal law is a daunting field. Requiring expertise in two different systems, the high barriers to entry make the number of scholars working in this area relatively few. Given all this, the Anglo-German Dialogue Project is perhaps the most ambitious and exciting endeavor in comparative criminal law now being undertaken.

Brenner M. Fissell

Review of Cooke, Amanda, Pensions and Legal Policy: Lessons on the Shift from Public to Private, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 229 pp, hb £70.00

Auto-Enrolment (AE), first introduced in the Pensions Act 2008, is a response to the dearth of private pension provision, designed to make it easier for the individual to make positive choices and harder for them to make negative ones. Amanda Cooke's monograph is a careful examination of both the behavioural economic basis of opt-out based policies and the effect that AE has had on workers, employers and pension providers.

Stephen Hawes

Review of Braithwaite, Jo, The Financial Courts: Adjudicating Disputes in Derivatives Markets, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020, 400pp, hb £95.00

This is an important work offering a wide-ranging and in-depth discussion of the role of courts in addressing complex financial transactions. In exploring the evolution of court decisions and their legal underpinnings, the book diverges considerably from other law books related to derivatives markets and it offers a fresh perspective on legal issues surrounding derivatives markets, which are worth trillions of dollars.

Christopher Chen

Review of Torrie, Virginia, Reinventing Bankruptcy Law: A History of the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2020, 245 pp, hb, £56.99

How do we effect true legal change? How does the legal system change its perspective on which interests the law should serve? What kind of balance should, and can, the law strike between the financial sector and the ‘Real Economy’? These are some of the fascinating and urgent questions raised by Virginia Torrie's intriguing and insightful new book, Reinventing Bankruptcy Law.

Joseph Spooner

The Review

Published January 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 85
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES