review article

The Process is the Rule and the Punishment is the Process

Rod Morgan

Abstract

Review of Andrew Ashworth, The Criminal Process: An Evaluative Study, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994, 315 pp, hb £45.00, pb £12.95 and Andrew Sanders and Richard Young, Criminal Justice, London: Butterworths, 1994, 496 pp, pb £18.95.

Fig leaf or no, The criminal justice system is real, with life-altering consequences for those caught up in it. The proportion of male citizens convicted of a listed offence by middle age is now estimated to be approaching forty per cent13 and, to adapt the title of a well-known book on the subject, for those caught up in it, the criminal process is the rule and the punishment is the process. The turmoil of current events therefore makes it imperative that we are clear about what principles should govern the criminal justice system. We need a road map to guide us through the competing claims currently being pressed. It is a need that the Runciman Commission Report largely failed to meet. How well do these two books offer guidance with regard to the contemporary debate?

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE