case

Damages for Breach of Contract — Compensation and ‘Personal Preferences’: Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth

Jill Poole

Abstract

There has been much debate surrounding the circumstances when it is possible to recover cost of reinstatement damages for breach of contract rather than the difference in the property’s value where the cost of reinstatement greatly exceeds that difference in value. In England, prior to the decision in Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth, a compromise position had been reached so that, as a general principle, it had been accepted that the larger cost of reinstatement damages would be the appropriate measure of damage if it could be shown that (a) it was reasonable to carry out the repair work, and (b) the employer had either cured the defect or intended to cure it. It appears that the majority of the Court of Appeal in Ruxley became so preoccupied with the question of the appropriate measure of damages that they neglected to correctly identify the loss itself.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE