article

Losses of Chances in the Law

Helen Reece

Abstract

Let us begin with two well-known principles. The first is that the standard of proof in civil cases is the balance of probabilities. The second is that in the tort of negligence the standard of proof is operated by using the ‘but for’ test: the negligence has to be a necessary cause of the loss. In most negligence cases, these principles occasion no controversy. The problems begin with those cases where it is difficult to decide what would have happened without the negligence. A first impression of these cases is that the decisions are arbitrary and inconsistent, and this is reinforced by the paucity of the judicial reasoning. In this article it is argued that a philosophical analysis enables us to grasp the distinction between the cases.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE