The Review

January 2023 Issue

articles

legislation

Will Listing Rule Reform Deliver Strong Public Markets for the UK?

There is a general consensus that the UK needs strong public equity markets. To help to ensure Britain is well-positioned on this front, the Financial Conduct Authority reformed the London Stock Exchange's listing regime in 2021 to foster initial public offerings (IPOs). This article outlines and evaluates these IPO-related reforms, assessing their potential to resuscitate the UK's public equity markets.

Brian R. Cheffins and Bobby V. Reddy

cases

The Heathrow Case in the Supreme Court: Climate Change Legislation and Administrative Adjudication

In Heathrow Airport, the UK Supreme Court allowed an appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision that there had been a series of legal errors in the designation of the Airport National Policy Statement. This note argues that the Supreme Court could have engaged more explicitly with the legal issues that arise from climate change legislation for administrative law adjudication.

Joanna Bell and Elizabeth Fisher

The Possibility of Lawful Act Economic Duress: Pakistan International Airlines Corp v Times Travel (UK) Ltd

The voidability of a contract procured by ‘economic duress’ is now well-established, but the precise boundaries of the doctrine remain contested. In Pakistan International Airlines Corp, the Supreme Court confronted the longstanding controversy as to whether a threat to perform a lawful act can provide grounds for a threatened party to avoid a contract for economic duress.

Timothy Pilkington and David Winterton

Cautious scrutiny: The Federal Climate Change Act case in the German Constitutional Court

In a unanimous decision of 24 March 2021, the German Federal Constitutional Court declared certain provisions of the Federal Climate Change Act unconstitutional. The Court upheld the greenhouse gas emission targets for the period until 2030 but found the outlined review procedure for the following years lacking: it failed to adequately specify targets, thereby violating the fundamental rights of the applicants.

Stefan Theil

Knowing receipt: continuing trusts and conscionability Byers v Saudi National Bank

In Byers the Court of Appeal examined a seemingly straightforward question: where rights are dissipated in breach of trust, is it a necessary condition of the recipient being liable for ‘knowing receipt’ that the dissipation did not extinguish the beneficiary's rights? This note argues that the Court of Appeal's analysis correctly supports the theory that so-called ‘recipient’ liability is in fact a species of liability for breach of trust.

Alexander Georgiou

book reviews

Review of Keith Ewing, Joan Mahoney and Andrew Moretta, MI5, the Cold War and the Rule of Law, Oxford, OUP, 2021, 511pp, hb £84.00

John Stalker, who investigated shoot-to-kill, was frustrated by ‘the denial that things had gone wrong, that no eggs were broken even though the omelette was there to see’. MI5, the Cold War and the Rule of Law, which investigates the security services in the same period, denies that things went right. It picks over eggshells while ignoring the omelette.

Ewan Smith

The Review

Published January 2023
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 86
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES