MLR Forum

07.10.25

The Ocean Treaty’s Novel Approach to Genetic Resources: A Response to Brad Sherman’s ‘Law in Non-Places’

This is a response to Professor Brad Sherman’s comment on my article ‘Unfree Commons: Freedom of Marine Scientific Research and the Status of Genetic Resources Beyond National Jurisdiction’, published earlier this year where I unpack a central constitutionalising norm of the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) Treaty. The Treaty will enter into force on 17 January 2026, and the first Conference of the Parties will follow within one year of that date.

Siva Thambisetty

06.05.25

Law in Non-Places: A Comment on Siva Thambisetty, ‘The Unfree Commons: Freedom of Marine Scientific Research and the Status of Genetic Resources beyond National Jurisdiction’ (2025) 88(2) MLR 300

Siva Thambisetty’s article is a timely review of the BBNJ Agreement which marks an important milestone in the regulation of genetic resources. While the article touches on many important topics, its main contribution is that it explains how the negotiators managed to ground the complex regulatory framework needed to implement the granulated approach to benefit sharing envisaged in the BBNJ. This comment places those arguments in historical context to reflect on the ‘unprecedented’ nature of the BBNJ.

Brad Sherman

18.04.24

‘Sovereignty and the Persistence of the Aesthetic’: Some Thoughts on Academic Writing

In moments of self-reflection, all legal academics must surely come to the realisation that much of the work they are obliged to read – and indeed write – is dense, obscure, monotonous, and repetitive. Surely our job is to clarify, to make complex topics more accessible. What makes ‘Sovereignty and the Persistence of the Aesthetic’ – on its face, a well-crafted article – an exemplar of poor academic writing is not its stylistic shortcomings: it is its ignorance about the position it seeks to correct.

Martin Loughlin

19.06.23

Defending the Orthodoxy: Central Bank Money as Liabilities: A Reply to Will Bateman and Jason Allen, ‘The Law of Central Bank Reserve Creation’ (2022) 85(2) MLR 401

Despite their importance in modern financial systems, central bank reserves have uncertain legal origin. Recently, Will Bateman and Jason Allen suggested a bifurcated view of reserve creation which specifies a ‘deposit pathway’ and a ‘transaction pathway’. I argue that this is misconceived, and that central banks create all reserves by issuing debt.

Shukri Shahizam

04.10.21

Of Chimeras, Ectogenesis, and Parenthood: Comment on Brian Sloan, ‘The “Chimera” of Parenthood’ (2021) 84(3) MLR 503–531

Brian Sloan’s analysis of the challenges a human chimera could pose for English law’s definition of fatherhood finds a parallel in the problems artificial wombs might raise for the designation of motherhood. While these hypothetical challenges point to important gaps in jurisprudence, a more pressing concern is the impact the limited flexibility of legally recognized parental roles in England has on already existing families.

Claire Horn

21.05.21

Hart’s Internal Perspective: Not a Matter of Endorsement? Comments on Alexander Somek’s Review of The Concept of Liberal Democratic Law

On the whole, Somek’s recent review of my book The Concept of Liberal Democratic Law is strikingly incongruous and self-contradictory. Considered in detail, it is grossly inaccurate and contains flagrant mistakes about elementary legal theory. Its tone and style, moreover, are unscholarly and un-collegial. In the comments that follow, I believe I make it abundantly clear that my book is not at all what Somek presents it to be.

Johan van der Walt

28.07.20

Stepping into the Normative Void: Comments on M Favale, M Kretschmer & PLC Torremans, ‘Who is Steering the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Justice? The Influence of Member State Submissions on Copyright Law’ (2020) 83 MLR 831

Intellectual property tends to be highly technical and of low political salience. Within the EU legislators tend to leave that complexity to be worked out by courts. Favale, Kretschmer and Torremans’ recent piece shows how the CJEU attempts to fill this ‘normative void’ and how Member States influence this process.

Luke McDonagh

22.07.20

Gender Self-Declaration and Women’s Rights: How Self Identification Undermines Women’s Rights and Will Lead to an Increase in Harms: A Reply to Alex Sharpe, ‘Will Gender Self-Declaration Undermine Women’s Rights and Lead to an Increase in Harms?’ (2020) 83(3) MLR 539

Alex Sharpe argues that gender self-declaration will not undermine women’s rights or lead to an increase in harms. We present the gender critical rebuttal, arguing that it indirectly undermines women’s rights to single sex spaces and that this will lead to harm.

Alessandra Asteriti and Rebecca Bull

20.04.20

Judging by Numbers: Comments on Gary Edmond and Kristy A. Martire, ‘Just Cognition: Scientific Research on Bias and Some Implications for Legal Procedure and Decision-Making’ (2019) 82(4) MLR 633

Experiments on bias demonstrate the inability of judges and jurors, and other professionals to shrug off so-called ‘anchoring’ effects, and other common cognitive biases. The goal of ‘Just Cognition’ is to interrogate precisely what these examples teach us about (the veracity of our assumptions about) how bias operates within the judicial sphere.

Tatiana Cutts

12.06.18

Responsibility and Reason-Responsiveness: Comments on John Gardner’s 2016 Chorley Lecture, ‘The Negligence Standard: Political, Not Metaphysical’, (2017) 80(1) MLR 1-21

Is it OK for the law to assign responsibilities to persons who lack the ability to respond to reasons? For John Gardner, the answer is 'normally, no'. Even when we do saddle those persons with responsibilities, we do so because we treat them, fictitiously, as if they are able to respond to reasons. Is that right?

Emmanuel Voyiakis

06.06.18

Hans Kelsen’s Judicial Decisionism versus Carl Schmitt’s Concept of the One ‘Right’ Judicial Decision: Comments on Stanley L Paulson, 'Metamorphosis in Hans Kelsen's Legal Philosophy' (2017) 80(5) MLR 860-894

Stanley Paulson's intriguing tracing of the developments of Hans Kelsen's work seems to maintain that Kelsen's decisionist stance of judicial decision-making was tamed by his constructivist 'Kantian' approach to law. While agreeing with Paulson’s jurisprudential analysis, a denial of the radicalism of Kelsen's decisionism often is the basis for the classic juxtaposition between his and Carl Schmitt's decisionist theory. But the opposite view is more appropriate: Schmitt's judge has much less room for individual political views than Kelsen's.

Jochen von Bernstorff

06.06.17

The Past and Future of the World’s Smallest Global Court: Comments on Tracy Robinson and Arif Bulkan, ‘Constitutional Comparisons by a Supranational Court in Flux: The Privy Council and Caribbean Bills of Rights’ (2017) 80(3) MLR 379–411

Robinson and Bulkan make a convincing case that the past and present of Judicial Committee of the Privy Council is of great concern for the future constitutional orders of the Caribbean, Commonwealth and United Kingdom. This note further explores the historical context to understand that future and its politics.

Coel Kirkby

08.05.17

A Time Traveller’s Guide to Law and Finance: Comments on Carsten Gerner-Beuerle, ‘Law and Finance in Emerging Economies: Germany and Britain 1800–1913’ (2017) 80(2) MLR 263–98

This comment connects Gerner-Beuerle's article on the evolution of company and securities law to the 'law and finance school', exploring the problems of original 'law and finance' research, Gerner-Beuerle's contribution in this direction, and suggesting how and why we may need a 'time traveller's guide' to law and finance.

Mathias Siems

24.04.17

Keeping It Real? Comments on Kimberlee Weatherall, ‘The Consumer as the Empirical Measure of Trade Mark Law’ (2017) 80(1) MLR 57-87

Professor Weatherall’s thought-provoking critique of the selective resistance to empiricism in trade mark law is a significant and welcome intervention. But the existence of certain structural features suggests that only a qualified turn to empiricism is possible, and the broader engagement between Law and Science holds other cautionary lessons.

Dev S Gangjee

The Review

For current and past issues of the review:

Preview