The Review

September 2024 Issue

articles

Rationalising Mid-Century Choice of Law: Legal Technique and its Limits in the ‘Dark Science’ of Conflicts

Under the common banner of a search for a ‘more rational’ approach to choice of law, US conflict-of-laws scholars of the late 1950s and the 1960s produced an impressive array of new technical instruments for their discipline. This article situates their work in the broader contexts of innovations in the social- and behavioural sciences and in legal- and political theory of this period.

Jacco Bomhoff

The Challenge of ‘Factual Hard Cases’ for Guilty Plea Regimes

This article examines how defendant self-conviction via guilty plea changes the application of criminal law, specifically in cases in which there is no right answer as to whether a defendant is guilty prior to trial, despite agreement over descriptive facts. These cases are referred to as ‘factual hard cases’. It suggests that defendants trying themselves in these cases creates risks for defendants and criminal justice systems.

Rebecca K. Helm

Priority Setting as the Blind Spot of Administrative Law Enforcement: A Theoretical, Conceptual, and Empirical Study of Competition Authorities in Europe

Priority setting by independent regulatory agencies (IRAs) is an invisible, yet essential, component of regulatory law enforcement. However, as a blindspot of administrative discretion, to date neither a normative framework to assess IRAs’ priority setting rules and practices nor a shared terminology to evaluate its different features has developed. This article fills this gap.

Or Brook and Katalin J. Cseres

legislation

Gambling Control in a Cost-of-Living Crisis: An Analysis of the White Paper High Stakes: Gambling Reform for the Digital Age (2023)

This article explains the broader stakes of contemporary British gambling reform debates, via an analysis of the White Paper High Stakes: Gambling Reform for the Digital Age (2023). I lay out the context to the White Paper, summarise its main proposals, and offer a critical analysis of one particularly significant and contentious proposed reform: mandated affordability checks for online gambling, when losses reach certain thresholds.

Kate Bedford

cases

Zedra Fiduciary Services (UK) Ltd v Attorney General: the Contemporary Scope of the Statutory Cy-près Doctrine

Historically, the cy-près doctrine required that, upon the substantive alteration of a charitable trust, the new purposes should be ‘as near as possible’ to the old. This is no longer the case and under the Charities Act 2011 the redrafting court or Charity Commission must have regard to factors other than proximity of purpose. Zedra is the first high-level authority to consider this statutory change.

John Picton

Byers v Saudi National Bank: What's the Wrong in Knowing Receipt?

In Byers, the Supreme Court held that where a right is transferred in breach of trust and the beneficiary's beneficial interest in the right is extinguished by the transfer, a personal claim for knowing receipt is not available against the recipient. Lord Briggs and Lord Burrows offered different reasons for this conclusion. This note argues that their approaches, while superficially similar, could lead to divergent results in future cases.

Rory Gregson and Timothy Pilkington

book reviews

The Review

Published September 2024
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 87
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES