The Review

July 2022 Issue

articles

Why Offences Specific to Prostitution are Unjustified

The criminalisation of prostitution takes various forms: some offences target sex-workers, others are aimed at third-parties (pimps or advertisers) or criminalise clients for consumption. I argue that existing theories cannot justify any offences specific to prostitution; hence, either current prostitution-specific offences should be extended to other types of sexual relations or the criminalisation of prostitution should be abolished.

Amit Pundik

The Evolution Of Elucidation: The Snowden Cases Before The Investigatory Powers Tribunal

In 2018 the ECtHR found that the UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal is an ‘effective remedy’ when it comes to reviewing the compatibility of the UK's domestic legal framework governing the interception of communication and other communications surveillance powers with the requirements of the ECHR. In particular, the Court praised the Tribunal's ‘elucidatory function’. This article shows how the elucidatory function evolved as a containment measure in response to unexpected crises of control over classified information.

Bernard Keenan

Governing Intersystemic Systemic Risks: Lessons from Covid and Climate Change

This article argues that contemporary regulation of climate change risks and zoonotic disease risks – two seminal risks of our era – is deficient because it fails to account for the most distinctive characteristics of their risk profiles. This calls for greater investment in assessment requirements, a less permissive approach to planning and development consent, and a commitment to phase out unsustainable production processes.

Veerle Heyvaert

legislation

e-Evidence Cooperation in Criminal Matters from an EU Perspective

For several years there has been debate among EU Member States on the need to regulate cross-border access to electronic data used as evidence in criminal proceedings and how best to do this. The existing model of cooperation, based mainly on bilateral agreements, appears dysfunctional and is perceived by many as a barrier to effectively combatting rising cross-border crime. This article discusses the current state of play and the expected shape of future regulations.

Marcin Rojszczak

cases

The Electrical Contractors Case: Irish Supreme Court Illuminates Collective Bargaining and Delegated Legislation

As Europe begins to emerge from the Covid-19 pandemic, two trends are clear: one, labour market reform is urgently needed, to cope with new economic and technological realities; and two, big government is back. In potentially one of the most important decisions in Irish labour law in decades, the Court rejected a constitutional challenge to legislation aimed at empowering social partners to regulate economic sectors through collective bargaining.

Alan Eustace

Human Trafficking, SM v Croatia and the Conceptual Evolution of Article 4 ECHR

Over the last decade the European Court of Human Rights has sought to reinterpret Article 4 ECHR in ways that render it applicable to human trafficking and modern slavery. Yet whilst this accorded Article 4 ECHR a vital role, ambiguity pervaded the question of what constitutes ‘human trafficking’; an issue that came to the fore in SM v Croatia, ultimately culminating in the first Grand Chamber human trafficking judgment.

Kirsty Hughes

Reconsidering Sentencing Principles in Cases of Civil Disobedience: Cuadrilla Bowland Ltd and Others v Persons Unknown and Others

Common law courts have struggled to offer a consistent basis for sentencing in cases concerning civil disobedience. This case note examines the recent Court of Appeal decision Cuadrilla Bowland Ltd v Persons Unknown, concerning individuals convicted of contempt for defying injunction orders to refrain from continuing their direct-action protests at a fracking site run by an oil company, with a view to immobilising its business operations.

Pok Yin S. Chow

review article

book reviews

The Review

Published July 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 84
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES