The Review

March 2022 Issue

articles

Undue Influence and Will Substitutes: Vitiating Transactions that Blur the Boundaries between Life and Death

An ageing population combined with decades of economic growth has correlated with a rise in inheritance disputes. While many of these disputes involve wills, non-probate instruments known as ‘will substitutes’ that operate during the donor's lifetime but also transfer specific assets upon death are playing a significant role. Our case survey reveals two distinct doctrinal approaches taken by the English courts to resolve these claims.

Ben Chen & Natalie Silver

The Law of Central Bank Reserve Creation

This article explores legal and constitutional dimensions of central banks’ powers to create money, ‘central bank reserves’, through monetary policy operations. Despite the prominence of monetary authority since the Financial Crisis, the law supporting the creation of central bank reserves is very obscure, as is the role of law in structuring constitutional authority over money. We de-mystify those important matters in three steps.

Will Bateman & Jason Allen

legislation

cases

Recognising What is Lost in Reproductive Harms: Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v XX

Whittington Hospital NHS Trust v XX (XX) turned on whether the courts should fund the creation of children for a woman negligently denied the ability to do so herself by awarding her the cost of pursuing surrogacy via a commercial service in California. While the subject matter of the decision is narrow, the decision in XX has broader implications about the relevance of public policy to damages awards.

Imogen Goold

review article

book reviews

Review of Simon Deakin and Christopher Markou (eds), Is Law Computable: Critical Perspectives on Law and Artificial Intelligence, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2020, xxi + 320 pages, hb £72.00

In broad terms, the chapters in this thought-provoking volume take one of two approaches to the question of law and computation. The first approach asks the theoretical question of whether or not computational reasoning carried out by artificial intelligence (AI) can effectively simulate or replace legal reasoning. The second approach considers pragmatic problems that data-driven technologies currently pose to the legal system.

Bernard Keenan

Review of Macmillan, Fiona, Intellectual and Cultural Property: Between Market and Community, Abingdon, Routledge, 2021, 232 pp, hb £120 e-book £25.89

This important book presents a philosophical contemplation of the possibilities for a strategic reimaging of intellectual property and cultural heritage law to better confront big issues surrounding culture, community and identity – cultural commodification, the geo-political history of the nation state, relations between the global North and South, post colonialism and indigenous rights.

Kathy Bowrey

Review of S. Cowan, C. Kennedy and V. Munro (eds), Scottish Feminist Judgments: (Re)Creating Law from the Outside In, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2020, 472pp, hb £95.00

Scottish Feminist Judgments is the latest addition to a ‘global initiative’ which aims to reimagine significant cases from a jurisdiction through a feminist lens. Sixteen judgments are included in the collection, presented across four categories: Crime, Victimisation and Violence; Family, Home and Belonging; Relational Duties, Equality and Discrimination; and Citizenship, Culture and Protection.

Rachel McPherson

Review of Adam Chilton and Mila Versteeg, How Constitutional Rights Matter, New York: Oxford University Press, 2020, viii + 388, hb £64.00

One of the biggest dilemmas that constitutional drafters face relates to rights to be enshrined in constitutions. How many rights should be included? What rights should be incorporated? How strong should rights’ protections be? In How Constitutional Rights Matter, Chilton and Versteeg utilise a mixed-method approach to study whether including a right in the constitution translates into governments being less likely to violate the said right.

Amal Sethi

The Review

Published March 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 85
Issue 2
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES