The Review

May 2021 Issue

articles

Strip‐Searching for Nationality Documents

Section 51 of the UK's Immigration Act 2016 introduced a new power to conduct strip‐searches for nationality documents on those held in immigration detention or in prisons. This article describes the wider legal context and analyses it from a human rights perspective. This includes an in‐depth examination of the administrative justification for this new power as well as a critical look at some of the issues with strip‐searching in practice.

Amanda Spalding

The ‘Chimera’ of Parenthood

In apparently the first reported instance of a paternity test being ‘fooled’ by a ‘human chimera’, a man ‘failed’ a paternity test because the genetic material in his saliva was shown to be different from that in his sperm. Chimeras present a challenge to legal systems, given the frequent emphasis on genetics in determining parenthood. This paper advocates the recognition of the chimeric person as the ‘true’ legal father and suggests two methods through which this might be accomplished.

Brian Sloan

Executive Accountability and National Security

The protection of national security has traditionally been an exception to general norms of public accountability, based on prerogative powers. The last three decades have seen efforts to bring national security closer to the normal constitutional control mechanisms of parliament and the courts. The design of and changes to mechanisms of accountability have, however, been accepted without discussion of the often narrower purposes for which they were first established. This article critically assesses these developments.

Lorna Woods OBE, Lawrence McNamara & Judith Townend

cases

Attribution: A New Controversy?

Although courts have generally endorsed the contextual, purposive approach to attribution, there remains significant uncertainty in its application. The Singapore Court of Appeal's decision in Red Star examined whether the claim brought by a solvent company against its fraudulent employee should be barred by the illegality defence where the person who was essentially the sole director and shareholder consented to the employee's fraud. This article argues that the reasoning and result in Red Star are questionable.

Ernest Lim

Tracing, Mixing, and Innocent Claimants

Faced with the problem that arises where multiple innocent claimants have contributed to a mixed fund that is now insufficient to meet all of their claims, English and Australian courts have suggested three solutions: (i) the rule in Clayton's Case; (ii) the ‘simple pari passu’ approach; and (iii) the ‘rolling charge’ or ‘North American’ approach. In Caron v Jahani (No 2) the New South Wales Court of Appeal adopted a simplified version of the third solution: the ‘simplified rolling charge’ approach. We argue that English courts should do the same.

Jordan English & Mohammud Jaamae Hafeez‐Baig

review article

Why Should Competition Lawyers Care about the Formal Rule of Law?

Competition law scholarship tends to be preoccupied with questions of substance. ‘More’ or ‘less’ intervention? Contentment or concern with concentrated markets? Which business practices should be prohibited? But the substantive reach of competition law – the ‘what’ we prohibit – cannot be divorced from questions of the legal form of market intervention – ‘how’ we determine legality. Bruce Wardhaugh's new book is notable for directly addressing questions of legal form in competition enforcement. Its novelty derives from a strong emphasis upon the formal rule of law. To those unfamiliar with European competition scholarship, such ‘novelty’ – and indeed responses to the title of this article – may seem banal. But that really isn't the case.

Ryan Stones

book reviews

Review of Robertson, Viktoria H.S.E., Competition Law's Innovation Factor, Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2020, 351 pp, pb, £76.50.

Innovation in its various forms and guises has been firmly in the limelight at least since the mid-1990s. Much of this attention, however, has focused on the substantive legal rules for innovation-related business conduct. Very few scholars have paid attention to the implications of innovation for a critical step in every competition law case – be it conduct enforcement or merger review – market definition. This is where Professor Robertson has made a valuable contribution to the field.

Thomas Cheng

Review of Herring, Jonathan, Law and the Relational Self, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020, 197 pp, hb £85.00

In Law and the Relational Self, Jonathan Herring promotes ambitious ideas for law reform to overcome the limits of liberal individualism and better accommodate caring relationships in the legal system. Several of Herring’s proposals have the potential, if implemented, to prevent the untimely deaths of persons living with disability and overcome other forms of harm that stem from contemporary laws and policies.

Roxana Willis

Review of Kay, John and King, Mervyn, Radical Uncertainty: Decision‐making for an Unknowable Future, London: The Bridge Street Press, 2020, 528 pp, hb, £25. 00

How do people make decisions in the real world, that is, in a world characterised by ‘radical uncertainty’? While seemingly elementary, this question has featured in academic discourses in economics, philosophy, law, and policy for centuries. Yet answers to it remain obscure. John Kay and Mervyn King’s Radical Uncertainty is the most recent attempt to provide a fresh look at how individuals, regulators, and other government officials choose the correct course of action in situations of uncertainty.

Sarah Arduin

Review of Duke, George and George, Robert P (eds), The Cambridge Companion to Natural Law Jurisprudence, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017, ix + 458 pp, pb £31.99

For its rearguard defence of natural law jurisprudence during the current ascendancy of legal positivism (for many, a losing battle), this is a seminal book worthy of our attention. The book features contributions drawn from a wide and diverse transAtlantic and transPacific authorship, alongside the most recent assemblage of the intellectual barony of natural law philosophy.

Bongi D. D. M. Radipati

Review of Hanretty, Chris, A Court of Specialists: Judicial Behavior on the UK Supreme Court, New York: Oxford University Press, 2020, 304 pp, hb £64.00

Quantitative empirical research on judicial behaviour is not yet as developed in the United Kingdom as it is in some other jurisdictions. Whatever the reasons, the result is that many interesting research questions that could be addressed through quantitative studies remain to be tackled. In his valuable and pioneering book, political scientist Hanretty sets out to answer some of those questions.

Mikolaj Barczentewicz

Review of Menke, Christoph, Critique of Rights, translated by Christopher Turner, Cambridge: Polity Press, 2020, 350 pp, hb £55.00.

What new insights might a new title on the criticism of rights offer to legal theory and jurisprudence? Following a long tradition in critical theory, Menke seeks to explain the genesis and necessity of the paradoxical form of modern rights. On the one hand, through the form of rights the law recognises individual freedom as a pre-political and pre-legal right; on the other hand, the law as a sovereign product, at the same time, permits and enables that freedom. An analysis of this paradoxical structure is the primary purpose of Menke’s book.

Eduardo A. Chia & Daniel Dodds

Review of Cheng, Thomas K., Competition Law in Developing Countries, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020, xii+580 pp, hb £80.00

Competition law, born and framed almost entirely in the developed nations of the West, has been adopted so widely since the 1980s, that developing countries now comprise the greater proportion of all countries that have such legislation in place. In his new book, Thomas Cheng focuses on a particular strand of this discussion,arguing emphatically that developing countries must adopt and enforce competition laws such that they contribute to their economic growth and further their development agenda.

Amber Darr

The Review

Published May 2021
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 84
Issue 3
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES