The Review

July 2024 Issue

articles

Police Use of Retrospective Facial Recognition Technology: A Step Change in Surveillance Capability Necessitating an Evolution of the Human Rights Law Framework

Retrospective facial recognition (RFR) marks a step change in police surveillance capability that has received surprisingly little attention to-date. As the legal issues surrounding RFR are uncertain, and as legal challenge is likely, this article makes four key contributions: setting out RFR and then assessing human rights implications and the common law 'in accordance with the law' and 'necessity' tests.

Daragh Murray

Natural Rights, Constituent Power, and the Stain of Constitutionalism

The power to make constitutions (the so-called constituent power) is predominantly understood today as a legally unlimited power belonging to the people. This understanding sits uncomfortably with constitutionalism: the idea that public powers are legally limited. Would such a power not leave an indelible blemish on constitutions that are otherwise committed to constitutionalism? This article shows that this problem, which I call the Stain of Constitutionalism, stems from a misapprehension of what constituent power was originally understood to be.

Raffael N. Fasel

cases

Vicarious Liability and Conferred Authority: Trustees of the Barry Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses v BXB

In Barry, the Supreme Court held that there was a single approach to determining all cases of vicarious liability and that the Court of Appeal had erred in placing significance on the authority conferred by the defendant on the tortfeasor to guide the behaviour of the claimant when determining vicarious liability. This note explores whether there is any role for conferred authority after Barry.

Christine Beuermann

Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose: Mackie Motors v RCI and Baird Textiles v Marks and Spencer

In Mackie Motors, the High Court and the Court of Appeal dismissed an argument based on the ‘relational contract’ in a way which recalled its dismissal 20 years earlier in Baird Textiles. It did not seem to have had any effect that after the 2013 ‘landmark decision’ of Leggatt J in Yam Seng v ITC the ‘relational contract’ has been considered an ‘established concept’ in a number of High Court decisions. But these decisions have all been received very coolly by the Court of Appeal, and the High Court decision in Mackie Motors may indeed represent an acceptance of the attitude of the Court of Appeal.

David Campbell

R (on the application of W80) v Director General of the Independent Office of Police Conduct: Landmark Ruling or Business as Usual?

The UKSC's affirmation in W80 that the criminal law test for self-defence is inconsistent with the purposes of the police conduct system on the use of force is to be welcomed. However, this case note argues that their Lordships’ reasoning in other regards was unconvincing and obscured deeper issues concerning police accountability which the recent Casey Review confirms need to be more openly addressed.

Clare Torrible

review article

book reviews

The Review

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES