The Review

January 1996 Issue

articles

Legal Analysis as Institutional Imagination

To grasp the potential of legal analysis to become a master tool of institutional imagination in a democratic society we must begin by understanding what is most distinctive about law and legal thought in the contemporary industrial democracies. In this effort no contrast is more revealing than the comparison of the substantive law and legal methods of today with the project of nineteenth-century legal science and the law of nineteenth-century commercial economies.

Roberto Mangabeira Unger

Constitutionalising Self‐Regulation

A member of a professional body is disciplined by that body and her licence to practice taken away. A firm is refused membership of an exchange or trading body on a ground not contained in the body’s rules. A person complains that the rules of a sporting association are discriminatory. Each seeks to challenge the associations’ decisions in the court. In the absence of legislation, how should the court respond? Various pre-occupations obscure the main issue: what should be the response of law when faced with what are in effect mini-systems of collective government? It is a question of how to constitutionalise self-regulation. The aim of this article is to begin to answer this question; to understand the constitutional issues raised by SRAs and the ways in which these are and could be addressed. The aim is not to reach the ultimate stage, a new theory for judicial review of self-regulatory associations, but to explore how we may begin that process and to offer a way forward which draws on some of the insights of reflexive law.

Julia Black

Civil Liability for Sexual Exploitation in Professional Relationships

This article argues that there are circumstances in which a victim of sexual exploitation should be entitled to bring a civil action for damages against the other party to the relationship. It begins by examining some of the evidence on the psychological effects of sexual exploitation. This provides a sense of where the law should concentrate in formulating the elements of an action based on sexual exploitation. Moreover, it establishes that sexual relationships arising from exploitation in professional relationships differ from ‘ordinary’ sexual relationships. It also shows that there are three possible characterisations of the wrongful act involved in sexual exploitation

Tom Allen

legislation

Privity of Contract and Leases — Reform at Last

The landlord and tenant relationship is governed by a vast body of case law and regulated by an increasingly large number of statutes. Nevertheless, there is a marked reluctance on the part of the legislature to interfere with the commercial property market, save where it has been considered absolutely necessary to protect tenants against an abuse of market power by landlords. The most recent legislative foray into the commercial rented sector, in the form of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, proved to be equally politically non-contentious. The principal achievement of the Act is, subject to important qualifications, to abolish the privity of contract principle.

Martin Davey

cases

Criminal Injuries Compensation: The Constitutional Issue

Even amongst recent causes celebres R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union stands out as exceptional. It is concerned with the most fundamental issues of our unwritten Constitution, namely the relationships between Parliament, the executive and the courts. It recognises explicitly, albeit in a dissenting judgment, the function of the courts to compensate for the deficiencies of Parliament, in holding the executive responsible for the misuse of powers, which Sedley J has characterised extra-judicially as ‘judicial assertiveness to compensate for, and in places repair, dysfunctions in the democratic process’. It is indeed a landmark decision which together with other notable recent cases heralds the assumption of a constitutional role by the judiciary in redrawing the boundaries between the courts and Parliament.

G. Ganz

Common Law Access to Medical Records

Seventeen years ago, Gerald Dworkin asked in this journal whether, apart from discovery proceedings, a patient has a common law right to see her medical records. The Court of Appeal has now for the first time answered this question - affirmatively - in R v Mid Glamorgan Family Health Services Authority & Another, ex parte Martin. In a unanimous decision, the court recognised that a health authority, in common with a private doctor, is under a common law duty to allow an individual access to her medical records except where, in view of potential detriment to her as a result of such access, it is not in her best interest to do so. Although the novel recognition in Martin of a common law-based right of access is to be welcomed, the decision maintains the paternalistic tradition of privileging medical control over personal health information - exemplified in Martin by the increasingly problematic use in novel medical law cases of a ‘best interests’ approach, coupled with a broad exception (to the newly recognised access right) framed in terms of mere detriment to the patient.

Dermot Feenan

Restitution where an Anticipated Contract Fails to Materialise

Following a tendering process, two parties enter into negotiations for a contract which they both confidently expect will materialise. One undertakes preparatory work or incurs expenses at the request of the other. But negotiations, through no fault of either party, break down, and a binding contract is never formed. The expenses, or remuneration for the work, clearly cannot be recovered as a matter of contract law. Must the party performing the work or incurring the expenses therefore bear the loss, or can the law of restitution be called in aid of recovery? This was the question which confronted Rattee J of the Chancery Division in the recent case of Regalian Properties plc & Another v London Docklands Development Corporation

Justin Mannolini

review article

From Deviance to Censure: A ‘New’ Criminology for the Nineties

Review of Colin Sumner, The Sociology of Deviance: An Obituary, Buckingham: Open University Press, 1994, xii + 340pp, hb £37.50, pb £12.99

The Sociology of Deviance charts the history of a field of inquiry; it is an archaeological exploration in the history of ideas. The sociology of deviance, in its mature form, comprised a set of concepts through which the raw materials of human society were seen, thought, comprehended and evaluated. But the sociology of deviance is now dead, Sumner argues, because its basic analytic is intellectually bankrupt: it is a way of seeing that can no longer tell us anything about what sort of societies we live in and what sort of people we are. This argument is unaffected by the survival of deviance discourse, and those university courses which dissect it, because the idea itself has run its course. All that is left is the empty, formal husk. If Sumner is right, the sociology of deviance would appear to be a suitable target for the orthodox view of criminological theorizing.

Paul Roberts

book reviews

January 1996 Book Reviews

William Lucy on Joseph Raz, Ethics in the Public Domain

Alison Dunn on Robert C. Palmer, English Law in the Age of the Black Death, 1348–1381: A Transformation of Governance and Law

Matthew H Kramer on Brian Bix, Law, Language, and Legal Determinacy

Philip Rumney on Ramsey Clark, The Fire This Time: US War Crimes in the Gulf

Christopher Hood on Anthony I. Ogus, Regulation: Legal Form and Economic Theory

Hazel Carty on Christopher Wadlow, The Law of Passing Off

John Lowry on Robin Hollington, Minority Shareholders' Rights

Various

The Review

Published January 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES