case

Common Law Access to Medical Records

Dermot Feenan

Abstract

Seventeen years ago, Gerald Dworkin asked in this journal whether, apart from discovery proceedings, a patient has a common law right to see her medical records. The Court of Appeal has now for the first time answered this question – affirmatively – in R v Mid Glamorgan Family Health Services Authority & Another, ex parte Martin. In a unanimous decision, the court recognised that a health authority, in common with a private doctor, is under a common law duty to allow an individual access to her medical records except where, in view of potential detriment to her as a result of such access, it is not in her best interest to do so. Although the novel recognition in Martin of a common law-based right of access is to be welcomed, the decision maintains the paternalistic tradition of privileging medical control over personal health information – exemplified in Martin by the increasingly problematic use in novel medical law cases of a ‘best interests’ approach, coupled with a broad exception (to the newly recognised access right) framed in terms of mere detriment to the patient.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published January 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230