The Review

September 1995 Issue

articles

Remedies and Remediation: Foundations Issues in Environmental Liability

Policy discussions of the law relating to pollution are peppered by frequent references to the ‘polluter pays’ principle. This principle has attracted almost universal rhetoric support and may seem to link neatly with the outcomes of at least some forms of civil liability. In the light of this, the present article will seek to emphasise that the way in which environmental ‘costs’ are conceived is an unavoidable element in any attempt to determine who should pay for such costs. The different legal techniques which have been suggested and debated as means of attributing liability may differ not only in the answers which they give to environmental questions, but in the very understanding of those questions which they permit. As such, this article is concerned with the impact and the limitations of different legal techniques in shaping legal responses to environmental damage, and to the increasing priority of environmental remediation

Jenny Steele

Informal Transactions in Land, Estoppel and Registration

The principal purpose of this article is to consider how well, or badly, the English system of land law and conveyancing handles the exceptional, but nonetheless important, cases of informal transactions in land. The article is in six parts. Part 1 points to the high degree of formality normally required for transactions in land and discusses the exceptional cases where informal transactions are permitted. Part 2 considers whether interests under proprietary estoppel can be fitted satisfactorily into a conveyancing system which increasingly, because of the spread of the title registration system, requires interests in land to be registered in order to bind subsequent purchasers. The conclusion reached is that both the registered and the unregistered land systems cope satisfactorily with such interests. In part 3, attention is turned to a well-known but difficult case, E R Ives Investment Ltd v High. In part 4 it is argued that Ives v High is but one example of a wider category of cases where the courts show themselves to be unhappy with the proposition that an unregistered interest can be defeated by a purchaser who has actual knowledge of that interest. This point is illustrated in part 5 by a brief examination of the Green family saga,2 and it is argued that the principal decision in favour of Mrs Green causes concern. Part 6 concludes the article with an argument for abolishing the protection given to a purchaser with actual knowledge, and some other proposals for reform.

Graham Battersby

Blasphemy, Cultural Divergence and Legal Relativism

At a point when legal developments around blasphemy are set to excite renewed controversy, this article explores the social and cultural significance of the offence and of the legal strategies which are in question. The initial section examines the involvement of the law of blasphemy in uncertainties surrounding the impact of secularisation and cultural pluralism, which invest it with considerable symbolic consequence. In order to illuminate the nature of the offence, there follows an account of its parameters and a critical analysis of its relationship to laws dealing with the adjacent areas of sedition, obscenity, outrage to public decency and offences against public order. The third section of the article is concerned with the recent revival of the blasphemy law and assesses the paradoxical nature of its effects, in particular the difficulties that have been posed for liberalism as a political philosophy aspiring to steer society through to an era of plurality and co-existence. Finally, the significance of a law of blasphemy is related to the question of the status of religion in contemporary western societies, the appropriate response of law, and the conflict that exists between the desire to rationalise the offence and the desire to equalise the protection it affords.

Clive Unsworth

Intention in the Criminal Law—A Rejoinder

Nicola Lacey’s article in this Journal, ‘A Clear Concept of Intention: Elusive or Illusory?’ tackles a breathtaking array of themes that are of central concern to criminal law scholars It would be impossible to do justice to all of her arguments in a single rejoinder. So, I want to concentrate on a narrow, but important issue. I want to show that Lacey’s assumptions about the role, if not the concept, of intention in the criminal law rest on a mistake. This is significant because, unless one understands the different roles that intention plays in the criminal law, one will not fully understand why the meaning of intention - the conception of the concept - may differ according to the role it is playing in a particular context. Then, by reinterpreting Moloney in the light of the role intention is playing in that context, I hope to cast doubt on her claim to have shown, through an analysis of intention in the criminal law, that one must have ‘a criminal law enterprise which dispenses with . . . the boundaries between criminal law and criminal justice, and which addresses criminal justice issues explicitly within a particular social and political context.

Jeremy Horder

In(de)terminable Intentions

Jeremy Horder’s rejoinder to my article on intention is an unusual member of the genre. First, it gives a clear and (generally) fair statement of the portions of my argument with which it is concerned. Secondly, and more importantly, it raises some significant points about criminal law doctrine and scholarship in its own right. Indeed, it does not really constitute a ‘reply’ to my article, for in relation to the two main theses which I was advancing, Horder is, as far as I can tell, in partial agreement with one and does not address himself substantially to the other. What he does is quite properly to point out that the relevance of intention in criminal law is broader than I explicitly acknowledged. My aim is not so much to reiterate or defend my arguments (something which in any case would not be possible in the space which the MLR has generously accorded me) as to clarify the points of genuine difference between Horder and myself so as better to allow our readers to judge the relative merits of our positions.

Nicola Lacey

legislation

Teleological Interpretation and Land Law

The effect of European Community law on English law has been uneven. Community law has, for example, had little impact on English land law. In future, however, Community law will have an impact on English land law, albeit a fairly modest one. The Directive on Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts was adopted on 5 April 1993. In the United Kingdom, the Directive has been implemented by the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations. The Regulations concern contracts concluded between consumers on the one hand and business sellers of goods or suppliers of goods or services on the other. If terms in such contracts have not been individually negotiated and are found to be unfair within the meaning of the Regulations, then those terms are unenforceable by the seller or supplier. However, both the Directive and the Regulations are silent as to whether land contracts involve a sale of goods or a supply of services, and hence fall within the scope of the Regulations. This omission has created uncertainty. The purpose of this note is to argue that the Regulations do apply to land contracts.

Mark Attew

Identity Cards

When the Home Secretary, Michael Howard, offered the public the long promised Green Paper on Identity Cards in May 1995, it had been expected that identity cards would be recommended to help provide reassurance for Tory waverers as well as a message that the Government remained capable of promoting innovative legislation. In addition, it was hoped that identity cards would assist the re-establishment of the Conservative Party as the natural protector of law and order. Given the slim and reducing parliamentary majority, it was felt within Government, up to the moment of dissent from the ‘Euro-rebels’ and right-wing MPs concerned about the ‘nanny’ state, that identity cards constituted an achievable parliamentary legislative proposal.

Philip A. Thomas

Decision‐Making for Life Apart

The Government’s recently published plans for divorce reform propose to replace the present divorce process founded on arms-length interactions among lawyers by one built around bilateral, party negotiations. Consistent with giving primary responsibility to the parties themselves, the proposals place reliance on mediation as the central mode of professional support, thus giving official impetus to the first of the three strands of development identified above. So, in Looking to the Future: Mediation and the Ground for Divorce, the radical ideas floated in the Lord Chancellor’s Department Consultation Paper of December 1993 survive broadly unchanged, if somewhat refined.

Simon Roberts

Reform of Public Law: Pragmatism or Principle?

It is disappointing to see that the Law Commission has sought to ignore considerations of legal principle in its recent Report, Administrative Law: Judicial Review and Statutory Appeals, which addresses many of the controversies - including the breadth of locus standi, exclusivity and time limits - which have arisen in public law over the last fifteen years. The Report’s rather pedestrian proposals are instead advanced within a generally pragmatic framework, and underlying debates concerning, for example, the nature of the interest which the citizen is vindicating in disputes with public bodies, or the nature of the distinction between public and private law, are not openly addressed. It will be argued here that purely pragmatic solutions are unlikely to assist in resolving many of the issues which currently attract controversy within public law. The Commission’s pragmatic and incremental approach instead raises questions about the future development of public law and the role of the Commission itself.

Nicholas Bamforth

cases

George Michael v Sony Music —A Challenge to Artistic Freedom?

Few commercial cases have attracted so much publicity in recent years as that involving the popular recording artist, George Michael, and his record company, Sony Music. The decision of the High Court, delivered by Jonathan Parker J, came down firmly in favour of the record company, thus reversing the recent trend of decisions in favour of the artist. However, it is likely that the story is far from over as an appeal has already been lodged. In the meantime, the entire record industry awaits the appeal with bated breath, as a decision in favour of the artist
will have profound ramifications on the way that European record companies currently do business.

Alan Coulthard

Enforcement of Rights to Worker Representation in Community Law

Imagine the situation: the Council of Ministers adopts Directives’ to protect worker interests. These Directives include an obligation on employers to inform and consult worker representatives when they contemplate redundancies and before the transfer of the undertaking. The UK government implements the Directives in national law in a manner which does not compel all employers to inform and consult. Indeed, in the majority of enterprises in the UK the employer is under no obligation to inform and consult because, as a matter of national law, there are no worker representatives. The question then arises: what, if anything, can the workers do about this? This is not an exam question, but real life. This note examines recent litigation in the ECJ, Commission of the European Communities v United Kingdom, and the High Court, Griffin and Others v South West Water Services Ltd, which (a) offers a case study in the inherent difficulties of implementing European social policy through Directives, and (b) fleshes out the nature of the obligation on employers imposed by the Directives.

Paul Skidmore

Libel and Pornography

Charleston v News Group Newspapers Ltd illustrates the unsatisfactory state of our law of defamation. The actual decision seems questionable even in terms of traditional libel principles. In the events that happened, the decision was not legally wrong, but those events should never have happened. The case seems to have been pleaded on the basis that readers, or some of them, would draw the inference that the plaintiffs were willing participants in a pornographic photograph. The defendants secured an interlocutory ruling requiring a preliminary issue to be decided by a judge alone; namely, whether the matter complained of taken in its proper context was capable of bearing the defamatory meanings alleged. The judge held that it was not, and the Court of Appeal and House of Lords agreed.

Peter Prescott

review article

Bringing Cinderella to the Ball: Teaching Criminal Law in Context

Review of Alan Norrie , Crime, Reason and History: A Critical Introduction to Criminal Law , London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1993, xx + 279 pp, pb £16.95.

Criminal law, we have been told, is the ‘Cinderella subject’ of the legal academy, always left at home to sweep the fireplace while the ugly sisters, contract and tort, dress themselves up in fancy theories and go to the ball. Criminal law is isolated and unappreciated, its charms hidden behind a drab black-letter appearance. Its true character, by implication, is something else, requiring the touch of a fairy godmother to transform the law so that, in a fairy tale ending, it may take up its rightful place in the heart of legal study. The course continues to be dominated by the study of general theories of liability and, though the importance of ‘context’ is now acknowledged, it continues to have a rather shadowy presence. It is this question - how the criminal law should be taught (and Cinderella be brought to the ball) - that is the subject of this essay. I shall argue that the divide between law and context is unhelpful and artificial, and actually perpetuates the marginalisation of context and, thus, we should abandon certain of our attempts to teach law in context.

Lindsay Farmer

book reviews

The Review

Published September 1995
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 58
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES