legislation

Reform of Public Law: Pragmatism or Principle?

Nicholas Bamforth

Abstract

It is disappointing to see that the Law Commission has sought to ignore considerations of legal principle in its recent Report, Administrative Law: Judicial Review and Statutory Appeals, which addresses many of the controversies – including the breadth of locus standi, exclusivity and time limits – which have arisen in public law over the last fifteen years. The Report’s rather pedestrian proposals are instead advanced within a generally pragmatic framework, and underlying debates concerning, for example, the nature of the interest which the citizen is vindicating in disputes with public bodies, or the nature of the distinction between public and private law, are not openly addressed. It will be argued here that purely pragmatic solutions are unlikely to assist in resolving many of the issues which currently attract controversy within public law. The Commission’s pragmatic and incremental approach instead raises questions about the future development of public law and the role of the Commission itself.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published September 1995
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 58
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230