article

Intention in the Criminal Law—A Rejoinder

Jeremy Horder

Abstract

Nicola Lacey’s article in this Journal, ‘A Clear Concept of Intention: Elusive or Illusory?’ tackles a breathtaking array of themes that are of central concern to criminal law scholars It would be impossible to do justice to all of her arguments in a single rejoinder. So, I want to concentrate on a narrow, but important issue. I want to show that Lacey’s assumptions about the role, if not the concept, of intention in the criminal law rest on a mistake. This is significant because, unless one understands the different roles that intention plays in the criminal law, one will not fully understand why the meaning of intention – the conception of the concept – may differ according to the role it is playing in a particular context. Then, by reinterpreting Moloney in the light of the role intention is playing in that context, I hope to cast doubt on her claim to have shown, through an analysis of intention in the criminal law, that one must have ‘a criminal law enterprise which dispenses with . . . the boundaries between criminal law and criminal justice, and which addresses criminal justice issues explicitly within a particular social and political context.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published September 1995
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 58
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230