The Review

September 1996 Issue

articles

The Law Commission: True Dawns and False Dawns

This article is primarily an account, drawing on cabinet papers, of the background to the enactment of the Law Commissions Act 1965. It seeks to highlight the matters which at the time seemed important to the officials and ministers involved. It will become apparent that there was real concern - not previously fully revealed - about significant constitutional issues, and that the Act now on the statute book was far more of a compromise than has been appreciated. It will also become apparent that some of the problems discussed 30 years ago still remain unsolved; but it should be emphasised that it is far beyond the scope of this article to attempt a comprehensive evaluation of the Commission’s role - past, present or future.

S M Cretney

A Case of Czech Beer: Competition and Competitiveness in the Transitional Economies

Among the leaders in the process of transition from a command to a free market economy is the Czech Republic. It is a popular destination for foreign direct investment. It faces considerable problems associated with the modernisation and capitalisation of its newly privatising companies. Consequently, such firms may be prime targets for foreign capital willing to undertake the commercial risk involved. Among the newly privatising firms and industries, some have a business potential that extends into international markets. A prime example is the brewing industry. This article examines the process in the context of one brewery which has made perhaps the greatest mark on international markets, Budejovicke Pivovary (Czech Budvar), famous for its ‘Budweiser Budvar’ lager beer.

P. T. Muchlinski

The Husband, the Bank, the Wife and Her Signature — the Sequel

In Barclays Bank plc v O’Brien, the House of Lords sought to resolve difficulties in the law applicable to disputes between creditors and surety wives. Typically, such cases involve a wife who, as a result of her husband’s unfair pressure or misrepresentation, provides third party loan security (usually over the matrimonial home) to a creditor for her husband’s business borrowings. Which of two ‘innocent’ victims (the wife or the creditor) should pay for the husband’s misconduct? Post-O’Brien cases indicate that the wife remains the most likely candidate, particularly in Court of Appeal cases. The limited legal protection available to sureties evident in post-O’Brien cases is explored in this article.

Belinda Fehlberg

legislation

Five Volumes in Search of Accountability: The Scott Report

What makes a good political scandal? The Arms for Iraq scandal had all the signs of a tale of secrecy and political deception fit for the period of insensitive, arrogant and dogma-ridden politics in which it was conceived and born. This note discusses in turn the Scott Inquiry's processes, its findings and its prescriptions on, first, parliamentary accountability and second, public interest immunity. Our conclusion is that, despite the most penetrating forensic examination in British constitutional history, the Scott Report has failed to correctly diagnose the disease or to apply the necessary cure.

Ian Leigh & Laurence Lustgarten

cases

The Tenant, his Wife, the Lodger and their Telly: a Spot of Nuisance in Docklands

The English law of nuisance is an unruly beast, insusceptible of exact definition, indiscriminately unleashed on a wide range of legal situations, marginalised or over-categorised in the textbooks. But this amorphous tort has proved very useful as an instrument of social policy, particularly in the environmental field. This is because it usually involves a revealing interplay of private rights and public interests, issuing, sometimes, in a quick and effective remedy in the form of injunctive relief. A recent decision on a number of preliminary issues by the Court of Appeal illustrates the contradictory position that the courts find themselves in when confronted with this public-private hybrid tort, in the context of public interests and private rights. Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd London Docklands Development Corporation raises three issues of fundamental importance to nuisance and its role in the regulation of land use: definition of the harm, title to sue and defences.

Rosalind English

Corporate Knowledge: Identification or Attribution?

The ascription to a company of the action, knowledge and fault of an individual has until recently been on the basis either that the individual was identified as the company or was the company’s agent. In its recent decision in Meridian Global Funds Management Asia Ltd v The Securities Commission, the Privy Council has rejected the identification approach and suggested that the principles of agency are but one aspect of the true principle upon which a company is bound, that of attribution.

Ross Grantham

Insurers, Privity and Procedure

Can the owner of a vehicle, who hires it out and provides in the contract of hire for the hirer to insure the vehicle, sue the insurer direct upon the policy of insurance taken out by the hirer, despite the doctrine of privity of contract, when the vehicle is lost? This was the substantive question posed in D G Finance v Scott and Eagle Star.' Despite very clear suggestions that in such circumstances a trust of the policy in favour of the owner should be inferred, so that a direct claim will lie, the Court of Appeal declined to answer this question in the affirmative, at least upon an application for summary judgment, and the indications are that the question would receive a final no.

N.S. Price

Restitution or Property? Priority and Title to Shares in the Conflict of Laws

The recognition of an independent law of restitution, based upon autonomous unjust enrichment, is now well established and welcome in English law. However, the precise scope of restitution, and whether claims that are presently explained on the basis of long-established principles should be reanalysed to fall within its scope, has yet to be fully determined. The appropriate choice of law rules for restitutionary claims within private international law have also yet to be clarified. Both of these issues arose in the course of the litigation in Macmillan Inc v Bishopsgate Investment Trust plc (No 3), but the Court of Appeal rightly took the view that the case was not the proper context in which to answer such complex and important issues, and instead confined itself to deciding that the lex situs governs issues of priority to the ownership of shares.

John Stevens

review article

Science, Evidence and Logic

Review of Bernard Robertson and G.A. Vignaux, Interpreting Evidence: Evaluating Forensic Science in the Courtroom, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 1995, xxi + 240 pp, hb £24.95.

Bayes’ theorem was used by Finkelstein and Fairley to show how probabilistic evidence could be combined with a fact-finder’s (subjective) evaluation of the prior probability of a defendant’s guilt. The authors proposed the explicit use of Bayesian methods in court and recommended that jurors be asked to quantify their prior probabilities in the interests of rational decision-making. Following on from Finkelstein and Fairley’s lead, other commentators have suggested that probability theory may help courts to make more rational, accurate decisions.’ Robertson and Vignaux’s work shares this perspective. Elsewhere they have argued that the conventional rules of probability provide the only rational way to analyse evidence and that legal rules which depart from the axioms of probability are wrong.’ They describe Interpreting Evidence as part of their wider project of logical analysis of evidential issues.

Mike Redmayne

book reviews

The Review

Published September 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES