The Review

November 2022 Issue

articles

Proof of Foreign Nationality and Citizenship Deprivation: Pham and Competing Approaches to Proof in the British Courts

This paper analyses competing approaches to proof of foreign nationality in the British courts, in the context of challenges to deprivation of citizenship. I argue that prevalent British approaches to proof are in unproductive tension with a fundamental principle of nationality law, namely that it is for each state to determine under its law who are its nationals.

Rayner Thwaites

Undermining Loyalty to Legality? An Empirical Analysis of Perceptions of ‘Lockdown’ Law and Guidance during COVID-19

Drawing upon the findings of a national survey undertaken during the first wave of the pandemic in June 2020, this article shows how the perceived legal status of lockdown rules made a significant difference as to whether the UK public complied with them and that this effect is a product of the legitimacy that law itself enjoys within UK society.

Naomi Finch, Simon Halliday, Joe Tomlinson, Jed Meers, Mark Wilberforce

legislation

Parliament, the Pandemic, and Constitutional Principle in the United Kingdom: A Study of the Coronavirus Act 2020

Constitutions come under pressure during emergencies and, as is increasingly clear, during pandemics. Taking the legislative and post-legislative debates in Westminster and the Devolved Legislatures on the Coronavirus Act 2020 (CVA) as its focus, this paper explores the robustness of parliamentary accountability during the pandemic, and finds it lacking.

Pablo Grez Hidalgo, Fiona de Londras, Daniella Lock

cases

Efobi v Royal Mail Group: Much Ado About Nothing?

Following the Supreme Court's recent decision in Efobi v Royal Mail Group, claimants in employment tribunals must first prove a prima facie case of discrimination before the burden of proof falls on the respondent to provide a non-discriminatory explanation for the impugned conduct. In reaching this decision, the Supreme Court failed to tackle squarely the important normative question at the heart of the dispute.

Jeremy Letwin & Josephine Rendall-Neal

Necessity, Non-Violent Direct Activism, and the Stansted 15: Reasserting ‘Hoffmann's Bargain’

In Thacker the Court of Appeal overturned the convictions of the ‘Stansted 15’ due to a misdirection on the substantive offence. However, the court rejected their necessity defence as their actions were political, outweighing a desire to avoid a risk of death or serious injury. We argue that this rejection of the defence is mistaken and overly broad for direct action cases.

Steven Cammiss, Graeme Hayes & Brian Doherty

Varying Contracts – Consideration, Form and Reality

In Ma Hongjin, the Singapore Court of Appeal confirmed that only contract variations supported by consideration are legally binding, Subsequently, in Charles Lim Teng Siang, the Court of Appeal held (obiter) that no oral modification clauses do not inevitably invalidate subsequent oral modifications. This note evaluates both decisions and concludes that their combined effect is to endorse a flexible framework for contractual variations in Singapore.

Pey-Woan Lee

Unreasonably Limiting Recourse to the Courts? R (on the application of Haworth) v HMRC

Follower notices, introduced in Finance Act 2014, can in certain avoidance situations be served on a taxpayer by HMRC where HMRC is of the opinion that the principles or reasoning of a decided case would deny the tax advantage in dispute. The Supreme Court judgment in Haworth addresses fundamental issues concerning access to the courts, the doctrine of precedent and balancing taxpayer rights against the public interest in the collection of taxes.

Michael Blackwell

review article

book reviews

The Review

Published November 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 85
Issue 6
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES