article

The International Extension of Denial of Justice

Jarrod Hepburn

Abstract

Denial of justice arises under customary international law when states prevent foreigners from accessing domestic courts. Certain states, scholars and arbitrators have maintained that an extension of the rule against denial of justice applies when states prevent access to international courts or tribunals. If correct, this extension would impose a significant control on states’ engagement with international adjudication. However, this article contends that the international extension of denial of justice is unsupported on any account of custom. A state’s interference with international adjudication might be treated as ineffective, or it might breach the instrument containing the state’s consent to the international claim. But this article argues that it does not, and should not, also breach the customary rule on denial of justice. The article therefore aims to clarify both the customary law in this area and the actual and desirable extent of states’ autonomy in their engagement with international adjudication.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published November 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 85
Issue 6
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230