The Review

November 1996 Issue

articles

Lord Woolf's Access to Justice: Plus ça change…

The Lord Chancellor appointed Lord Woolf in March 1994 to review the rules of civil procedure with a view to improving access to justice, reducing the cost of litigation and removing unnecessary complexity. The aim of this paper is not to provide a detailed commentary on the Woolf Report. Rather, the discussion will concentrate on the strategy adopted for reducing the cost of litigation. It will be argued that the cause of excessive cost lies not in the complexity of our procedure, but in the incentives that lawyers have to complicate litigation.

A. A. S. Zuckerman

Hans Kelsen's Earliest Legal Theory: Critical Constructivism

Legal positivism in the jurisprudential tradition of the European Continent is characterised by what might be called the facticity thesis: the law is ultimately explicable in terms of, or ‘reducible to,’ a concatenation of fact - whether it be power, the will of the sovereign, or the community’s acceptance of the legal system Kelsen’s conviction that the facticity thesis is wrongheaded drives his theory, particularly in the very early work. In place of the legal positivist’s facticity thesis, Kelsen introduces a normativity thesis, which calls for an explication of law - and of legal obligation in particular - altogether independently of fact.

Stanley L. Paulson

Listening to the Law: Famous Trials on BBC Radio, 1934–1969

In this article I consider a form of popular culture peculiarly British, BBC radio, and examine the development of an immensely popular programme form, the reconstruction of notorious legal cases. The history of BBC trial reconstructions reflects the changing nature of the BBC itself, as the Corporation moved from the days of patrician Edwardian austerity into a more liberal and egalitarian postwar Britain. It records the changing nature of the society of which the BBC was a part. It suggests changes in the way the trial system is perceived and represented. Tracing the evolution of famous trials programmes helps us to understand a little of how knowledge of law moves from the legal to the popular domain and, in turn, how the conventions of popular culture structure popular legal knowledge.

Suzanne Shale (formerly Gibson)

legislation

Domestic Violence: The New Law

After a torrid passage through Parliament, the Family Law Act 1996 finally received the Royal Assent on 4 July 1996. This article is concerned only with the domestic violence provisions of the Act. This article discusses four main features of Part IV of the 1996 Act against the background of its general scheme: the question of who will be able to obtain the orders; the injustices created by pockets of deficient draftsmanship; the interrelationship between the Act and existing legislation on the provision of local authority housing for those driven from their home by a violent partner; and the inadequate nature of, and scope for, potential police involvement under the Act.

John Murphy

Back to the Future on Sentencing: The 1996 White Paper

Few government proposals in the recent troubled history of penal policy can have generated such sustained debate and controversy as those contained in its latest White Paper, Protecting the Public: The Government’s Strategy on Crime in England and Wales. The cautious note of optimism which greeted the 1990 White Paper has given way to a chorus of criticism and widespread disillusionment among criminal justice academics and practitioners regarding the general direction of penal policy since the Criminal Justice Act 1991.

Ralph Henham

cases

Positive Action After Kalanke

The acknowledged failure of EU intervention to bring about substantive equality between the sexes has been documented, but attempts made to address some of the institutional structures which lead to the lack of substantive equality have attracted criticism and controversy, particularly the use of positive action programmes. The ruling of the Court of Justice in Kulunke v Freie Hunsestadt Bremen has brought the debate over the fairness’ and utility of positive action programmes on to the political and legal agenda once again.

Erika Szyszczak

Pre‐Natal Injury and Transferred Malice: The Invented Other

The doctrine of transferred malice has few champions among academic lawyers. It operates to explain the decision of a court in cases where an accused, acting with the requisite mens rea of an offence, causes a result which is unintended in some way. In many criminal law courses, this topic tends to be dealt with by a cursory reference to some nineteenth-century cases, with little discussion of its applicability in recent times. In view of this, it is surprising to see the doctrine being given a new lease of life by the Court of Appeal in Re Attorney General’s Reference (No 3 of 1994)

Mary Seneviratne

review article

Justice and Ethnicity

Review of Will Kymlicka, Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995, 280pp, hb E19.99.

It is now one of the well-known ironies of the 1990’s that global economic and social integration has intensified rather than soothed cultural and ethnic sensitivities. Ethnicity has re-emerged from the shadows to become one of the central issues of the decade. These are interesting times for ethnic rights specialists and many have found themselves in demand, both in academia and beyond. Among these, Will Kymlicka has recently confirmed his reputation as a leading thinker on issues of justice and ethnicity with the publication of his book, Multicultural Citizenship, a work which should be well received on both sides of the Atlantic.

Perry Keller

book reviews

November 1996 Book Reviews

Michael Salter on Alan Brudner, The Unity of the Common Law: Studies in Hegelian Jurisprudence

John Murphy on Andrew Grubb and Maxwell J. Mehlman (eds), Justice and Health Care: Comparative Perspectives

Colin Crawford on Genevra Richardson and Hazell Genn (eds), Administrative Law and Government Action: The Courts and Alternative Mechanisms of Review

John Lowry on Elizabeth Boros, Minority Shareholders' Remedies

Mohammed Rasekh on Michael J. Zimmerman, The Concept of Moral Obligation

Various

The Review

Published November 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 6
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES