article

Fact‐finding in Inter‐state Adjudication

Saju Jacob

Abstract

Inter-state disputes that have arisen for adjudication before the International Court of Justice reveal variations and inconsistencies in the nature of judicial fact-finding. Justifying these variations as the products of coincidence or error is unsatisfactory and fails to illuminate the underlying reasons for factual decisions. These reasons remain shrouded in uncertainty, leaving the rationale for the peculiar nature of fact-finding to speculation. This article suggests a theoretical framework within which decisions of fact by the International Court can be scrutinised and rationalisations sought between factual findings and substantive verdicts.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE