case

Human Trafficking, SM v Croatia and the Conceptual Evolution of Article 4 ECHR

Kirsty Hughes

Abstract

Over the last decade the European Court of Human Rights has sought to reinterpret Article 4 ECHR in ways that render it applicable to human trafficking and modern slavery. Yet whilst this accorded Article 4 ECHR a vital role, ambiguity pervaded the question of what constitutes ‘human trafficking’; an issue that came to the fore in SM v Croatia, ultimately culminating in the first Grand Chamber human trafficking judgment. This analysis piece responds to these developments by drawing out and reflecting upon the conceptual framework for human trafficking and Article 4 ECHR, identifying what we now know, and equally what remains unknown, about this important right. In this regard it highlights significant differences of opinion within the Court. Underpinning those differences are diverging views as to both the scope of Article 4 ECHR, and the role of the Court, such that radically different future directions remain both possible and contested.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published July 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 84
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230