review article

Examining the Structure of Remedial Law: Review of Stephen A. Smith, Rights, Wrongs, and Injustices: The Structure of Remedial Law, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019, 368pp, £80.00

David Winterton & Timothy Pilkington

Abstract

Conventionally, a judicial private law remedy (JPLR) is understood as a court order made following two types of events: a violation of a legally recognised right, or a threatened violation of a legally recognised right. In Rights, Wrongs, and Injustices: The Structure of Remedial Law, Stephen Smith rejects the prevailing explanation of the primary and secondary duties in JPLRs. Smith argues, first, that although certain JPLRs are made on the ‘grounds’ of threatened rights violations, many of the JPLRs that courts issue are instead made on the ‘grounds’ of ‘wrongs’ or ‘injustices’. Secondly, Smith argues that the idea of ‘secondary legal duties’ is largely misplaced and that, prior to a judicial ruling, rights violations only give rise to legal liabilities. The book, which is the culmination of many years’ work, is an original and thought-provoking work of scholarship demanding serious engagement. This review makes three principal claims: first, the reasons that Smith provides against the existence of a ‘secondary’ legal duty to pay ‘compensatory damages’ are unpersuasive; second, the taxonomy of damages awards that Smith advances should largely be rejected; and third, Smith’s argument that all restitutionary orders following ‘defective transfers’ are made on the ‘grounds’ of ‘injustices’ is doubtful. As explained below, these criticisms substantially undermine the ‘structure’ of ‘remedial law’ that Smith defends.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published September 2021
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 84
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230