book review

Review of Steven Ratner, The Thin Justice of International Law: A Moral Reckoning of the Law of Nations, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015, 471 pp, hb £50.00.

Alejandro Chehtman

Abstract

Steven Ratner’s book The Thin Justice of International Law provides an assessment of the international legal system at the bar of justice. This is a book clearly written against the current. Although for centuries international lawyers were seriously concerned with deeper normative questions, today this type of exercise is quickly – and often mistakenly – dismissed as natural law. This charge often conflates the claim that the law must be morally defensible (ie, that unjust laws warrant criticism, reform, and under certain circumstances disobedience) with the claim that law and morality are internally connected. The type of ethical evaluation of legal institutions that Ratner proposes is an instance of the former, not necessarily the latter.

Ratner’s book will not be short of detractors. They may find the specific substantive claims he advocates less objectionable than his intellectual enterprise. Nevertheless, that kind of judgment would b e short-sighted. This book constitutes an ambitious and rigorous attempt to build bridges with other relevant disciplines in order to better understand the moral strengths and shortcomings of the international legal system. Ratner pushes international legal theorists into tackling new and pressing questions. Indeed, contemporary legal theory has experienced a slow transition away from the classical jurisprudential questions, towards more substantive issues. International legal theory – currently concerned mainly with traditional questions such as interpretation or positivism – may well profit from following this trend.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published September 2016
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 79
Issue 5
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230