The Review

May 2022 Issue

articles

Between Microeconomics and Geopolitics: On the Reasonable Application of Competition Law

For decades competition law was interpreted and applied through the prism of the economic analysis of law. Such a ‘standard’ perception of the discipline, however, is in a deep crisis. The conceptual divide between the representatives of Law and Economics and those adhering to a more societal account of competition law has many levels and dimensions. This article investigates the foundational aspect of the divide: the divergence in epistemic perception of legal and economic expertise.

Oles Andriychuk

The Governance of Economic Unionism after the United Kingdom Internal Market Act

With the United Kingdom having finally withdrawn from the European Union, and with a new Trade and Cooperation Agreement in place to begin to manage their economic relationship, it might be thought that the constitutional drama of ‘Brexit’ was finally at an end. Yet the longer-term constitutional implications of Brexit and its repatriation of the European regulatory state are becoming apparent.

Kenneth A. Armstrong

Two Ways of Looking at a Printed Book

This article revisits a recent debate in copyright scholarship surrounding the dominant utilitarian-proprietary approach to copyright and its limits as identified by three readers of Immanuel Kant's 1785 essay, ‘On the Wrongfulness of Reprinting’. Although these scholars have demonstrated the power of Kant's essay and its concept of the book as communicative act to reshape our understanding of authorship and copyright, they have also underestimated the material dimension of the text that affords the production of its meaning.

Benjamin Goh

legislation

cases

Adieu to Attribution

Applying the illegality defence to corporate claims remains one of the most vexed issues at the interface of the law of obligations and company law. In Singularis Holdings Ltd v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Ltd, the Supreme Court held this defence did not bar a company from suing its bank for negligently failing to stop the company's controlling director from misappropriating funds. While the result is defensible, the decision fails to resolve some important uncertainties.

Qinhao Zhu

The CJEU in Commission v Hungary Higher Education Defends Academic Freedom Through WTO Provisions

The CJEU in Commission v Hungary Higher Education ruled that the legal conditions introduced to enable foreign higher education institutions to carry out their activities in Hungary are incompatible with EU law. This note explains that Commission v Hungary Higher Education is the latest example of the ongoing efforts in Hungary to undermine the rule of law and threaten academic freedom in the EU.

Andi Hoxhaj

The Future of Employment: Purposive Interpretation and the Role of Contract after Uber

A person's entitlement to workplace rights and protections under English law is conditional on their relationship falling within the legal category of employment, by virtue of them having the requisite status. The employment status of individuals performing on-demand work via digital platforms is particularly contentious and has been a focal point for debate in recent years. Uber BV v Aslam represents a ground-breaking judgment on this issue.

Joe Atkinson & Hitesh Dhorajiwala

review article

book reviews

Review of Lavrysen, Laurens and Mavronicola, Natasa (eds), Coercive Human Rights: Positive Duties to Mobilise the Criminal Law under the ECHR, Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2020, 328 pp, hb, £63.00

How much criminal law do we want? The question of the proper use of criminal law's coercive power remains as complex and challenging as ever. This is the question at the heart of this edited volume, contemplated through 13 chapters on the ECHR: how much criminal law should European human rights law want and mobilise?

Ergün Cakal

Review of Spano, Robert, Motoc, Iulia, Lubarda, Branko, Albuquerque, Paulo Pinto, Tsirli, Marialena (eds), assisted by Lazana, Aikaterini, Fair Trial: Regional and International Perspectives/Procès équitable: perspectives régionales et internationales. Liber Amicorum Linos-Alexandre Sicilianos, Brussels: Anthemis, 2020, 764 pp, €150.00

Honoring former Presidents of the European Court of Human Rights has become tradition over the past years. The present Liber Amicorum brings together some fifty essays written in English and French by eminent scholars and practitioners celebrating the innovative thinking of former President Linos-Alexandre Sicilianos as both international law scholar and human rights judge.

Ioannis Prezas

The Review

Published May 2022
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 85
Issue 3
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES