The Review

July 2023 Issue

articles

Prisoner Voting in the United Kingdom: An Empirical Study of a Contested Prisoner Right

Do prisoners’ rights matter? This paper examines this question through a social-legal study of one of the most controversial prisoners’ rights issues of recent decades: prisoner voting. Thousands of prisoners are legally eligible to vote in the United Kingdom. Drawing on a survey of 134 electoral administrators, we explore whether they are exercising that right and the potential barriers to electoral participation which they face.

Robert Jones & Gregory Davies

What's Choice Got to Do With It? Addressing the Pitfalls of Using Choice-Architecture Discourse Within Poverty Law

In legal scholarship, as in other fields, it would seem that ‘choice-architecture’ (where states attempt to ‘move’ people toward desired behaviour) is everywhere. This paper argues that such blanket adoption of choice-architecture discourse cannot be based on generic terms, nor on imagined or assumed choices. Rather, I contend, the specific characteristics of each legal field – here, poverty law – should be considered when debating and reviewing choice-architecture.

Yael Cohen-Rimer

Skeleton Keys to Hospital Doors: Adolescent Adults who Refuse Life-Sustaining Medical Treatment

We consider how the sufficiency of young adults’ autonomy is judged in light of biological, social and psychological evidence that adolescence can continue into the mid 20s. Until then, adolescent adults are prone to developmental immaturity which can affect risk taking, impulsivity, and independence in decision making. We argue that the right to full decision-making about medical treatment refusals at 18 based on the adult status of the individual should accommodate greater sensitivity to individual developmental attributes and set out three ways in which that might be achieved.

Emma Cave & Hannah Cave

legislation

cases

Armstead v Royal Sun Alliance Insurance Company Ltd: The Interface between The Winkfield and Conarken

In Armstead v Royal Sun Alliance Insurance Company Ltd, the Court of Appeal considered the limits of the ‘proprietary fiction’ established by The Winkfield, allowing bailees to recover loss through their possessory title of bailment property against a wrongdoer. This note argues that the bailee's claim against the wrongdoer arises solely from the possessory title (without reference to the bailor) and the ordinary rules of tort should apply after establishing such title.

Yeqiu (Dan) Huang

book reviews

Review of Federico, Picinali, Justice In-Between: A Study of Intermediate Criminal Verdicts, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2022, 278 pp, hb £80.00

In Justice In-Between, Picinali examines intermediate verdicts (IV) in criminal cases. An IV is a third option that sits between ‘guilty’ and ‘not guilty’. It is rigorously argued, rooted in an understanding of criminal procedure and, without doubt, provides food for thought to those who have never questioned the binary verdict system.

Fiona Leverick

The Review

Published July 2023
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 86
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES