The Review

January 2021 Issue

articles

Guilt Beyond Guilt: From Political Theory to Metaphysics with Herbert Morris

As it is presently conceptualised and applied in criminal law, moral guilt is bound by a narrow, legalistic framework that is rooted in a liberal political philosophy. In this paper, drawing on the work of Herbert Morris, I seek to open up and deepen the concept of moral guilt. I do this through the development of a four‐fold typology of guilt that charts Morris's journey from political theory to metaphysics.

Amanda Wilson

British Torture, Then and Now: The Role of the Judges

This article is concerned with the return of torture and other related abusive conduct to the British counter‐insurgency arsenal following the initiation of military engagements in Afghanistan and Iraq in the early 2000s. It focuses primarily on how judges have engaged with the challenges that this torture and abusive conduct have posed, both in their capacity as judges proper and also as appointees to a range of inquiries that have been initiated in the wake of these actions.

Conor Gearty

cases

book reviews

Review of Ting Xu and Alison Clarke (eds), Legal Strategies for the Development and Protection of Communal Property, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018, 256 pp, hb £65.00.

The volume edited feeds into recent scholarship on collective use of crucial resources by adopting the specific standpoint and vocabulary of communal property. It provides a theoretical and empirical reflection on the legal strategies that are and should be put in place to develop and protect communal property in relation to land and other natural resources across different legal systems (England and Wales, Scotland, Italy, Israel, Cameroon, South Africa, and China).

Fabiana Bettini

Review of John Eldridge and Timothy Pilkington (eds), Sir Owen Dixon's Legacy, Sydney: The Federation Press, 2019, 272 pp, hb $150 AustSir Owen Dixon, Jesting Pilate and Other Papers and Addresses, 3/e edited by Susan Crennan and William Gummow, Sydney: The Federation Press, 2019, 336 pp, hb $120 Aust.

The last year witnessed renewed interest in Sir Owen Dixon, one of Australia's preeminent jurists, with the publication these two books. They provide timely encapsulations of his legacy for law students, scholars and practitioners in the common law world and wider political domain.

Andrew Clarke

Review of Imogen Goold, Jonathan Herring and Cressida Auckland (eds), Parental Rights, Best Interests and Significant Harms – Medical decision‐making on behalf of children post‐Great Ormond Street Hospital v Gard, Oxford: Hart, 2019, 256pp, hb £54.00

This timely collection, edited by three of the UK's leading experts in medical law and ethics, examines the case of Great Ormond Street Hospital v Gard, drawing on legal, medical, philosophical and sociological perspectives to explore the roles of parents, doctors and the courts in making decisions on behalf of critically ill children.

Claire Fenton‐Glynn

The Review

Published January 2021
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 84
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES