Abstract
In The Politics of Judicial Independence in the UK’s Changing Constitution, the authors present the results of a three-year research project that involved consultations with judges, lawyers, politicians and other stakeholders to better understand the independence and accountability of the UK judiciary. The book will be of considerable interest to both constitutional lawyers and political scientists because of its detailed account of the changing nature of courts and judges in the UK. More broadly, it offers a re-imagining of how judicial independence works within a legal system. While the bulk of scholarly literature on judicial independence tends to be normative in the sense that it prescribes what is seen as necessary to achieve an independent court, the authors take a different approach by focusing on what they describe as the ‘politics of judicial independence’. By this, the authors do not mean the ideological preferences of judges but rather a view of judges as actors working inside a dynamic system of justice. Instead of seeing judicial independence simply as a collection of rules or institutional arrangements to protect judges, the authors envision it as a living idea, defined and re-defined by ongoing interactions and evolving relationships among judges and between judges and politicians, which includes formal and informal aspects. The authors point out that there is only a clear consensus about the meaning of judicial independence at a high level of generality. By framing the study on the politics of judicial independence, the authors move past abstractions to capture a broad range of interactions and the practicalities of independence. This is an important dimension often neglected by others. Its value can be seen throughout the book as each chapter reveals the contested application of judicial independence to day-to-day situations, its meaning being hammered out by the judiciary and the executive. The authors, however, are quick to note that these interactions take place within a ‘long-standing and vibrant culture of judicial independence’ (8).
CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE| Published | November 2016 |
|---|---|
| Frequency | Bi-monthly |
| Volume | 79 |
| Issue | 6 |
| Print ISSN | 0026-7961 |
| Online ISSN | 1468-2230 |
Previous Review Issues
Select a previous issue of the Modern Law Review