The Review

November 1995 Issue

articles

Photographs and the Rights of the Individual

The photograph is pervasive in all areas of modern life. The ease with which the
photographic image can be captured, transferred around the globe and, more
importantly, changed and interfered with, has increased the vulnerability to abuse. Nevertheless, methods to regulate such abuse, where they exist, have received little attention from Parliament, the courts or legal scholars. The fact that
photography is all-pervading, however, should only serve to draw attention to the problems of control, not to suggest that they are insoluble. The purpose of this article is to consider some of the major uses to which photographs are put and to examine whether the safeguards against abuse, which human rights standards may demand, are adequate. Particular attention will be drawn to the principles relevant in ‘balancing’ the pressing social needs of order and crime prevention with the right of the individual to behave as he pleases.

Ralph Beddard

A Postmodern's Hart: Taking Rules Sceptically

This essay proceeds on the raison d’etre that the past and its heroes are better respected through active engagement than through passive veneration. I want to put a revived Hart to work in the hectic world of contemporary concerns rather than leave him to be admired as an historical curiosity in the jurisprudential Hall of Fame. Such an undertaking can illuminate a very different Hart from the one caricatured in contemporary legal literature. Rather than be the country bumpkin to contemporary theory’s urbane sages, he appears as a much more prescient and balanced theorist. To do this, I offer a postmodern reading of Hart; it is more a re-view than a review. By this, I do not mean that I will attempt to demonstrate that Hart was really a postmodernist at heart (although such a challenge is tempting). Instead, I will read Hart from an avowedly postmodern perspective - the fact that some of my conclusions may not be seen to fit snugly with those that many think are crucial to the Hartian canon is beside the point.

Allan C Hutchinson

Tort, Insurance and Ideology

In this article I will deal with tort’s relationship with insurance. Concentrating first on the common but vague claim that tort is somehow ‘about insurance,’ I will argue that neither actual insurance nor insurability are or should be relevant to the reach and shape of tort liability. I then hope to explain why continued confusion on this point can lead to the conflation of tort with the insurance model of response to misfortune. Once this ‘tort as insurance’ construction of liability is embraced, the normative agenda for the future of tort inexorably points to retrenchment: an agenda, it can then be claimed, which arises from the mere logic of what tort is bout and not from any ulterior ideological motive. Exploding the ideological subtext of the ‘tort as insurance’ fallacy then frees us not only to formulate coherently the central question of the future of tort (this is the question of which of life’s misfortunes justify the full restorative response tort extracts from the defendant), but also to admit the ideological nature of the analysis required for resolution of this question.

Jane Stapleton

legislation

Monopoly, Prohibition and Deterrence

The Trade and Industry Committee of the House of Commons, responding to complaints by consumer groups and industrial enterprises, investigated the substantive and procedural aspects of monopoly legislation, and reported in May 1995. The report makes much of the distinction between the UK investigatory system which provides ex post control and the prohibition system of Article 86 EC, under which monopoly abuse is not only prohibited ex ante but is subject to heavy fines. A constant theme of the report is that the current UK system is uncertain, subject to the influence of personalities and politics, and lacks a predictive quality. The Committee would have done well to concentrate on the two important questions: (i) is it desirable to move from an uncertain ‘public interest’ test to an uncertain ‘abusive conduct’ test? (ii) Does the power to fine provide an effective incentive to refrain from abusive conduct?

Tim Frazer

cases

‘The Status to be Accorded to Motherhood’: Case C‐32/93, Webb v EMO Air Cargo (UK) Ltd

In Webb v EMO Cargo (UK) Ltd, the House of Lords referred the issue of whether an employer could dismiss a pregnant woman employed on an indefinite contract but whose more immediate task was to provide cover for another woman due to take maternity leave. The ECJ ruled that the protection afforded to a woman during pregnancy and after childbirth cannot be dependent upon whether her presence was essential to the proper functioning of the employer’s business. To adopt any other approach would render the Equal Treatment Directive ineffective. The result in Webb is not surprising and perhaps of transient importance in the employment field. But in arriving at its conclusions, the ECJ has created even more ambiguities, questioning the commitment of EC law to protecting women at a time when they are most vulnerable.

Erika Szyszczak

Allocating Health Care Resources in an Imperfect World

Despite the publicity generated by R v Cambridge District Health Authority, ex parte B, it could be argued that the decision, that courts have little or no role to play in the allocation of health resources, represents merely the orthodox public law position. Nevertheless, the litigation and the distressing circumstances which lie behind it do encapsulate important issues and dilemmas within our society and it is the purpose of this note to explore some of these. In particular, it will be argued that to characterise this case as representing a conflict of interest between medicine and law, as though law was trespassing on medical or health administration, is mistaken and demonstrates a misunderstanding of the role of law in our society.

Alan Parkin

Care by the Family or Care by the State?

The law relating to children encompasses a number of profoundly difficult issues. One of the most serious questions with which a court may have to grapple is when should it authorise a local authority to receive a child into their care against the wishes of the child’s parents or other family members? Provisions in the Children Act 1989 are designed to achieve the delicate balancing act between justifiable and unwarranted state intervention into family life. In Re M (A Minor) (Care Order: Threshold condition), these provisions came under scrutiny, first by Bracewell J, then by the Court of Appeal and finally by the House of Lords.

Mary Hayes

Dangerous Defects Revisited by Bold Spirits

May a builder be held liable in tort to a subsequent purchaser of a building, with whom the builder is not in contractual privity, for the cost of repairing dangerous defects arising out of negligent construction? The House of Lords, in D & F Estates Ltd v Church Commissioners for England’ and in Murphy v Brentwood District Council, has said ‘no.’ The Supreme Court of Canada recently has replied ‘yes,’ in Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No 36 v Bird Construction Co Ltd.

Laura C.H. Hoyano

Assisted Suicide in the Netherlands: Postscript to Chabot

The decision of the Dutch Supreme Court in the Chabot case - involving the criminal prosecution of a psychiatrist who had acceded to the request of a psychically traumatised but not otherwise ‘sick’ woman (Mrs B) for assistance with suicide - was reported in an earlier issue of MLR. The regional Medical Disciplinary Tribunal subsequently concluded that what Chabot had done ‘undermined confidence in the medical profession’ (the basic disciplinary norm). Chabot received a relatively severe sanction: ‘reprimand.’ On 19 April 1995, Chabot announced that he had had enough of legal proceedings and would not appeal this decision, which means that the case is now finally closed. The purpose of this brief postscript to the earlier report of the Supreme Court’s decision in the criminal case is to provide some basic information about and comments on the subsequent decision of the Medical Disciplinary Tribunal.

John Griffiths

review article

Corporate Governance: A Defence of the Status Quo

Review of J.E. Parkinson, Corporate Power and Responsibility: Issues in the Theory of Company Law, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993, xxv + 464 pp, hb £50.00, pb £19.95.

Corporate governance issues, and in particular the social responsibilities of major corporations, have long been the subject of academic debate in the United States. Such debate in the United Kingdom has been sporadic, but does seem to have intensified in the aftermath of the 1980s boom. The most comprehensive recent attack on the UK’s system of corporate governance of major public companies is found in Parkinson’s book, Corporate Power and Responsibility. Parkinson, like a number of other academics, sees corporations as powerful ‘social enterprises’ and the current, basically Victorian system of corporate governance as archaic and particularly unfitted to the rise of the complex multinational group. In this article, I examine his arguments, try to draw attention to some of the weaknesses in his case and suggest that the status quo still has much to recommend it.

Alistair Alcock

book reviews

The Review

Published November 1995
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 58
Issue 6
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES