article

Historiography and Constitutional Adjudication

William Partlett

Abstract

Lawyers and judges often use history in constitutional adjudication to provide context for constitutional interpretation. But there is debate about the extent to which historiography – the critical study of how history is written, developed by professional historians – is relevant to constitutional adjudication. This article argues that historiography has little relevance to constitutional reasoning grounded on historic legal sources such as court cases or legislation. But when constitutional reasoning relies on non-legal, general historical sources, historiography provides important insights. Arguments based on general historical sources – particularly originalist ones – can and should be critiqued on historiographical grounds. These methods show that general historical sources are unlikely to generate precise and objective constitutional meaning but can be used to develop and constrain many constitutional arguments, including those concerning constitutional practice, purpose, or values. Historiographic methods are important for lawyers and judges seeking to critique or make constitutional arguments grounded on general history.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published May 2023
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 86
Issue 3
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230