The Review

May 1996 Issue

articles

Do Markets Degrade?

The reasons for limiting the reach of markets - either by making certain things inalienable at a price or by conferring special protections on tradable items - are many and varied. The purpose of this article is to examine one particular reason which is sometimes used to justify such limiting of markets: that markets can have a degrading effect. Although there may sometimes exist strong feelings that markets do degrade certain goods and activities, such feelings do not in themselves justify the placing of limitations or prohibitions on the commodification of those goods and activities.

Neil Duxbury

The Quest for Legitimacy in the European Union

Whilst it is true that the European Community has always, to some extent, been a contested political entity, the debate in recent years about the role and future of the European Union has increasingly focused on its legitimacy. The need to enhance the legitimacy of the Community has been a familiar theme of the many reports and proposals for its reform over the years, most recently during the time of the ‘Maastricht’ debate on the Treaty of European Union in 1992 and 1993. However, it is largely since the Maastricht process that the debate on the European Union has been in terms of a ‘crisis’ of legitimacy. I propose to examine the debate on legitimacy in the European Union, the language in which it is conducted and the nature of the values at its heart.

Gráinne de Búrca

The Inertia of Institutional Imagination: A Reply to Roberto Unger

Today, as ever, Roberto Unger challenges us to place our concept of the political at risk. Much of his recent work renews his earlier call for an empowerment of politics, involving our constant alertness to the possibilities of change, the revisability of those possibilities and the removal of all that falsely presents itself as unrevisable. This call for the empowerment of politics is not, of course, couched in the vocabulary of republicanism, as so much other recent legal theory is. But neither is it an appeal to the smashing of all contexts, to the tireless resistance to the institutional; no, Unger’s great novelty is that his politics are both radical and institutional.

Emilios A. Christodoulidis

‘Upping the Ante’: Market Distortion in Auction Sales

Auctions play a crucial role in the United Kingdom economy, a vast array of goods (and land) being bought and sold through this form of transaction. It is the purpose of this article to examine the legal basis, and the consequences of, some of these practices. Whilst some activities of auctioneers may depress the price obtained, price boosting is of greater concern. Buyers are presumably content to pay prices fixed by genuine competition. What they are likely to be less sanguine about is to discover that bids they have over-topped have in fact come not from others in the room intent on buying but, rather, from the seller himself.

F. Meisel

legislation

Caring for Patients in the Community

The Mental Health (Patients in the Community) Act 1995 is an attempt to reconcile opposing views about the provision of care for people with mental disorder returning to the community. Is it appropriate that people who are no longer ill enough to require treatment in hospital should be made subject to a legal regime which restricts their movements and activities, or is the policy of community care failing patients because of a lack of staff and resources? The Act comes down firmly in favour of a new legal regime, intended as a response to widespread concern fuelled by a number of incidents, that some disordered people in the community are a danger either to others or to themselves.

Alan Parkin

Digital Broadcasting: The Government's Proposals — The Doubtful Revolution

In August 1995 the Government published a policy paper’ on its proposals to introduce digital technology to terrestrial broadcasting. When one examines the proposals in more detail, the imminent revolution looks a little less apparent. On the one hand, the proposals are likely to produce a cumbersome and complex regulatory scheme which may act as a disincentive to broadcasters to commit themselves to the very considerable investment expenditure required to begin digital services. On the other hand, the proposals also raise more serious issues than just their lack of regulatory elegance.

L.P. Hitchens

cases

Accessory Liability for Breach of Trust

In Royal Brunei Airlines v Tan, the Privy Council introduced a new test, replacing
Lord Selborne’s formulation in Barnes v Addy, of the liability of an accessory to a breach of trust, that is, a person other than a co-trustee who assists trustees to commit a breach of trust, but without himself receiving any of the trust’s asset. Although the judgment has been widely welcomed, this Comment will argue that its basis in previous case law is unsound, that the judgment contains inconsistencies on the key issue of whether knowledge of the breach of trust is a necessary condition of an accessory’s liability, and that the Privy Council’s preservation of a separate head of equitable liability for assisting a breach of trust is illogical and anomalous.

Alan Berg

Lords Design Constraints

The decision of the House of Lords in R v Registered Designs Appeal Tribunal, ex parte Ford Motor Co Ltd adds to the requirements of aesthetic and technical autonomy a third: in order for a design to be registrable, the article to which it is applied must ‘have an independent life as an article of commerce and not be merely an adjunct of some larger article of which it forms a part. The words of the ex parte Ford decision suggest a view of the commodity form that requires it to be commercially autonomous, to be viewed standing alone like some exhibit at the Crystal Palace in 1851.

Lionel Bently

World‐wide Mareva Injunctions in Common Law Canada

The province of British Columbia has joined the growing list of jurisdictions whose courts are prepared to grant world-wide Mareva injunctions. This development provides a strong indication that this order is available from all Canadian superior courts. However, the circumstances in which a world-wide Mareva injunction will be granted and the test to be applied are in a state of confusion. So too is their underlying function. Mareva injunctions are available not only to restrain the active dissipation of assets, but also as a form of security according to the recent and widely publicised decision in Mooney v Orr and Dorfman, which is the focus for this Comment.

John Arnold Epp

review article

The Philosopher‐Judge: Some Friendly Criticisms of Richard Posner's Jurisprudence

Review of Richard A. Posner, Overcoming Law, Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1995, x + 597pp, hb $29.95.

Richard Posner has put together a very good book indeed. The latest of his numerous works is a sprawling melange of book reviews and other essays that have appeared elsewhere, combined with several important essays that have not previously been published. Failings the book has, however, and they will occupy our attention throughout the rest of this review. We shall begin by looking quickly at several problems that would deserve more sustained exploration had we but world enough and time. The focus then turns to more significant problems that are examined in greater depth. In all of the criticisms and queries below, the intent is constructive; the aim is to suggest how a very strong theoretical stance can become even stronger.

Matthew H. Kramer

book reviews

May 1996 Book Reviews

Aurora Plomer on Ronald Dworkin, Life’s Dominion: An Argument about Abortion and Euthanasia

Peter Muchlinski on M. Sornarajah, The International Law of Foreign Investment

David Cowan on Ian Loveland, Housing Homeless Persons: Administrative Law and the Administrative Process

Mike Redmayne on David A. Schum, The Evidential Foundations of Probabilistic Reasoning

Martin Loughlin on R. C. van Caenegem, An Historical Introduction to Western Constitutional Law

Owen McIntyre on Randall L. Erickson and Robert D. Morrison, Environmental Reports and Remediation Plans: Forensic and Legal Review

Various

The Review

Published May 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 3
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES