Abstract
While researching his The Anatomy of Britain (1962), Anthony Sampson met David Maxwell Fyfe (who, on taking up the position of Lord Chancellor in 1954, had become Viscount Kilmuir). Sampson was struck by Maxwell Fyfe’s amiability but later recorded in his notebook that the Lord Chancellor had ‘a second-rate brain’ (13). Alongside this unflattering assessment, Sampson set the fact that Maxwell Fyfe worked hard. In his Viscount Kilmuir: A Vignette, Neil Duxbury tells us that Maxwell Fyfe would have agreed with Sampson’s assessment of his abilities and approach to his work. This prompts the question as to why we should spend time reading about someone who, on his own assessment, compared unfavourably with political and legal contemporaries who possessed sharper minds. Duxbury’s answer to this question is that even ‘humdrum’ figures can have ‘historical significance’ and, for this reason, their lives may merit scrutiny (5-6). This point certainly applies to Maxwell Fyfe. For he used his abilities in ways that enabled him to engage in ‘day-to-day political and legal problem solving’: eg, addressing the threat to the public interest posed by monopolies and other restrictive trade practices (13). More importantly, he played an influential role in the European Movement after World War Two. He was, for example, one of the ‘three main authors’ of the European Convention on Human Rights (106). For these and other reasons that Duxbury brings into view, we might see Maxwell Fyfe as pursuing a career that throws light on law as a politico-legal institution. Duxbury touches only lightly on this point by, for example, describing Maxwell Fyfe as a ‘lawyer statesman’ (90). However, his exposition, as we will see, lends strong support to it.
CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE| Published | March 2017 |
|---|---|
| Frequency | Bi-Monthly |
| Volume | 80 |
| Issue | 2 |
| Print ISSN | 0026-7961 |
| Online ISSN | 1468-2330 |
Previous Review Issues
Select a previous issue of the Modern Law Review