article

Establishing Liability in Criminal Networks

Shachar Eldar

Abstract

Organised crime has long been framed in structural terms, characterised by hierarchy, membership, and assigned roles. Hence, this framing is the standard view adopted by criminalisation doctrines when it comes to determining culpability and wrongdoing. Crucially, however, a growing body of criminological research shows that organised criminal activity is migrating away from hierarchical structures and toward more diffuse, looser-knit network models. These rely on myriad individuals who facilitate the criminal endeavour – by acting as vetting agents, financiers, or coordinators, for instance – yet do not participate in any specific crimes. Can criminal law effectively hold such individuals to account? This article argues that it cannot: those who knowingly sustain harm-enhancing networks without perpetrating or assisting in discrete offences escape liability, despite their genuine moral culpability. Tackling this ‘network gap’ requires confrontation with a deeper tension in criminal law theory, between the individual actions on which liability must ultimately rest and the collective structure from which those actions derive their wrongfulness. Taking this tension into account and drawing on current criminological literature, the article proposes a coherent normative foundation for criminalising network facilitation. The proposed approach is empirically grounded in documented network patterns, guards against overcriminalisation, and establishes principled criteria for graduated liability.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published July 2026
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 89
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230