book review

Review of Rabeea Assy, Injustice in Person: The Right to Self-Representation, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015, xxiii + 233 pp, hb £70.00.

Paul Roberts

Abstract

The self-evident legal status of the (assumed) right to self-representation is Rabeea Assy’s first target in this original and sure-footed monograph. His second target is the right itself, which Assy regards as devoid of any convincing rationale, at least in the context of civil litigation between private individuals. In this, Assy is swimming against the tide of prevailing policy wisdom (or ‘iconoclastic’, if you credit Hazel Genn’s Foreword), inasmuch as current governmental thinking is predicated on the assumption that traditional juristic language and trial procedure should be adapted to facilitate effective self-representation by lay ‘consumers’ lacking any specialist legal knowledge or training. This policy orientation is all the more significant in a time of shrinking, or in some quarters disappearing, legal aid budgets. How does Assy fare in propounding his revisionist thesis? Very well, in my estimation. This is a compelling piece of legal scholarship in the best traditions of counter-intuitive normative jurisprudence.

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published July 2017
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 80
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230