The Review

July 1996 Issue

articles

Regulation and the Public Interest: Commercial Gambling and the National Lottery

The National Lottery etc Act 1993 (the 1993 Act) introduced into Great Britain and Northern Ireland a state lottery similar to those that are commonplace within the rest of the European Union and in North America. The main theme of this article is that the public interest argument in favour of the expansion of gambling opportunities in the name of good causes threatens to compromise the structure within which the National Lottery is regulated. This structure is overseen by a new statutory agency established by section 3 of the Act, the Office of the National Lottery (OFLOT), and is a structure that has for some years been employed in the pursuit of a countervailing argument in favour of their containment.

David Miers

Fundamental Rights, Fair Trials and the New Audio‐Visual Sector

The media reporting of court trials, especially those concerning criminal matters, has long been recognised in this country as creating potential conflicts of interest and clashes of rights. Radical developments in the new audio-visual sector now create the possibility that the ECHR layer of normative regulation will in turn become inadequate or at least marginal. The purpose of this article is, first, to describe briefly the relevant features of the new audio-visual media; and, second, to identify the problematic capacities they have developed in relation to established forms of regulation, both national and international, which seek to balance free speech and fair trials. Thirdly, it will be considered what regulatory or other responses, based on a wider view of ‘governance’ might appropriately be advanced.

Clive Walker

The Limits of Justice: Finding Fault in the Criminal Law

Crime is a serious social problem to which society does not have a serious answer. Loud voices say that if our stock responses fail, we need more of the same. It should be easier to detect and convict criminals, punishments should be harsher. The resulting calls for ‘law and order,’ with emphasis on the latter, endorse what we may call the ‘penal equation.’ This is the simple formula, ‘crime plus responsibility equals punishment,’ that has informed our social control practices for two hundred years. The rationale for this equation is that crime requires punishment as retribution and deterrence, and criminal justice qualifies individuals as deserving of the state’s legitimate sanctions. It is this sense of justice, responsibility and desert, justifying social control through criminal punishment, that is the focus of this paper.

Alan Norrie

Kicking Corporate Bodies and Damning Their Souls

In the fierce controversy over corporate criminal liability, one phrase rings through the literature: a company has ‘no soul to be damned and no body to be kicked.' Less often quoted are the words that preceded these: ‘Did you ever expect a corporation to have a conscience?’ and the ones that allegedly followed them: ‘by God, it ought to have both.’ The argument in this article is that, for the purposes of the criminal law, modem companies can be regarded (at least metaphorically) as having both bodies and souls that, through the censure and stigma of punishment, can be both kicked and damned in the hope of inculcating a corporate conscience

C.M.V. Clarkson

legislation

Criminal Appeal Act 1995: The Semantics of Jurisdiction

This statute is informed by a certain history, which it will continue. The original statute setting up a Court of Criminal Appeal, the Criminal Appeal Act 1907, was passed against great opposition from a number of senior judges,’ in response to a number of high-profile miscarriage of justice cases. The Criminal Appeal Act 1995 has been enacted in response to similar events, although in this case with the direct approval of the Lord Chief Justice and other senior judges. The purpose of this note is to consider what there might be in this Act, if anything, which will substantially alter the practice of criminal appeals. We would argue that neither of these reforms of themselves will alter the practices of the Court of Appeal.

David Schiff & Richard Nobles

cases

Citizenship of the Union? Lessons from Carvel and The Guardian

On 19 October 1995, the Court of First Instance of the European Communities ruled in favour of a British journalist (supported by his newspaper) in an action brought against the Council of the European Union with regard to its decision to refuse access to Council documents. In itself, the judgment marks a rather limited inroad into the secret world of the Council. However, it is suggested that the significance of the case lies in its exposure of the ambiguous nature of Union citizenship and the significance of the inter-institutional dialogue as the Union’s primary mode of operation.

Kenneth A. Armstrong

Pregnancy Discrimination

On 19 October 1995, in Webb v EM0 Air Cargo (UK) Ltd (No 2), the House of Lords interpreted the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 to give effect to, but also create some ambiguity as regards, the ruling of the Court of Justice. Initially, the House of Lords felt that the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 was clear: it was not contrary to that Act to dismiss a woman for being unable to carry out her contract of employment if a man would receive comparable treatment in similar circumstances. Thus, the provision of national law was not ambiguous. The question was whether the Act should and could be interpreted in a different way so as to give effect to EC obligations without distorting the meaning of the Unfortunately, questions on procedure and the scope of indirect effect did not form part of the Article 177 EC reference.

Erika Szyszczak

Contract Damages for Injury to Reputation

Recently, in Malik v BCCI, the Court of Appeal was confronted with the question whether in an action for breach of contract, damages are recoverable for injury to the plaintiffs reputation. The plaintiffs were employed by the (now) collapsed Bank of Credit and Commerce (BCCI). Unbeknown to them, the bank was involved in dishonest and fraudulent activities. Following the collapse of the bank, these fraudulent activities were discovered. The plaintiffs’ contracts of employment were terminated by the bank’s liquidators; and the plaintiffs were unable to gain fresh employment because of the stigma attached to them as former employees of the bank. They claimed damages for this injury to their employment prospects. The claim failed.

Nelson Enonchong

review article

The Classical Legacy and Modern English Contract Law

Discussions about English contract law are characterised by a deep division of opinion between traditional and critical contract lawyers. The gulf between the two schools centres on their attitudes towards the classical model of contract, the general theory of voluntary obligation which developed in the second half of the last century. The essays in the collection under review, indicate that three central aspects of the classical conception of contract are in the firing line. First, the emphasis on the independence and distinctiveness of contractual obligation. Secondly, the ideology of freedom of contract and the prominence given by that ideology to the autonomy of the contracting parties. And, finally, the ideal of a unified law of contract characterised by rules of general application.

Donal Nolan

book reviews

The Review

Published July 1996
Frequency Bi-Monthly
Volume 59
Issue 4
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230

Virtual Issues

Virtual Issues contain curated content drawn from the MLR

GO TO VIRTUAL ISSUES