book review

Review of Liav Orgad, The Cultural Defence of Nations: A Liberal Theory of Majority Rights, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016, 273 pp, hb £50.00

Robert Schertzer

Abstract

In The Cultural Defence of Nations, Liav Orgad engages with one of the most pressing issues of contemporary politics and constitutionalism: the relationship between majority and minority groups. Increasing levels of migration, particularly to Western states, have driven a host of majority-minority conflicts that rightly preoccupy academics and policy makers alike. The rise of the far right in Europe, the ‘failure’ of multiculturalism, Brexit, security concerns, and the Syrian refugee crisis are all part of the backdrop for this book. To say it is timely is an understatement.

Orgad’s entrance into the well-trodden debate on the relationship between majority and minority groups, however, brings forward an interesting and unique perspective. Rather than advocating for the rights of minority groups, as many before him have, this book considers and makes a case for the rights of majority groups to defend their culture. By tackling head on a fundamental paradox in liberalism – the inability of liberal regimes to protect their values without recourse to illiberal means (135) – Orgad’s analysis deconstructs many contemporary immigration and citizenship policies of Western states, all with a view to building a more defensible and ‘justifiable’ means for these states to actively promote and ‘protect their culture’ (12).

CONTINUE READING FULL ARTICLE
Published January 2017
Frequency Bi-monthly
Volume 80
Issue 1
Print ISSN 0026-7961
Online ISSN 1468-2230